Today
Jakarta

Sun, 04/06/2008 10:44 AM | Headlines
Sitting at a warung the other afternoon, I overheard the predictable litany of complaints against Indonesia's taxi drivers. Smugly the overseas guests said they had managed to get a good price to the airport from Kuta. "I told him I would pay 20,000 rupiah and that was it. You've got to be tough," said this foreign visitor, who interspersed his conversation with what low prices he had managed to get for his shipment of crafts, which he was set to make a packet on back home.
Within me was a boiling urge to pop this self satisfied character on the nose. At no point had this chap, or his business colleagues, considered the life of a taxi driver in Indonesia. Perhaps they were looking only through the eyes of their home countries where taxi divers usually pull 12 hour days for fairly miserable wages. But they do get to go home and sleep, they have their taxis supplied and normally earn an hourly rate.
Things here are a bit different. I recently took a taxi from Jakarta's airport into the city. Chatting with the taxi driver I discovered he works 24 hours a day, he lives in his taxi. His family is way up in Bandung, a couple of hours up the freeway. He has not been home in four months. He has been living this way for 20 years. He is a friendly chap who complains not at all; happy to have a job and the meager earnings that help to keep his kids in school.
At the same warung a woman is whining about the difficulty of getting a visa into Indonesia. "I have to fly to Malaysia and then come back. It's expensive. I am on a pension," she blisters as she tucks into a meal that costs around 10,000 rupiah or a dollar in U.S. terms. So often I hear people complain about the difficulties they face getting an Indonesian visa. There is a choice of visas available from the 30 day tourist visa on arrival, the Social Budaya that extends up to six months and for the business mob it's an easy two months that lets them traipse around the country and fill containers with profit.
Good for them, good for Indonesia, so why the whining. All visas take is a trip to Singapore, or if you prefer some real color, Dili, and a couple of days wait and you are right for another couple of months in paradise. Try getting the same visa into Australia, the U.S. or Europe, particularly if you are an Indonesian citizen. The fact is Indonesia has some of the most generous and welcoming visa requirements in the world, we should be very, very grateful.
Just outside the entrance to the warung is a young Indonesian girl, perhaps 9 years old. She will never have the opportunity to travel to distant lands. Dusty faced, hair unwashed, dressed in hand me downs that have been handed down too often, she begs for Rp 1,000, 500 if you could spare that. The bitter pensioner complaining of visa costs refuses this beggar child the 10 cents she asks for. "They are all rich you know, these beggars," she says. I am not so sure. Begging is hardly a career of choice.
Giving to these poor buggers is a win win situation. The beggar gets a bowl of rice; the giver gets far more, a reminder "that there but for the grace of God go I", that dash of humility that wipes smugness from the soul. Yet the complaints from guests go on.
Next up is the price of accommodation. A swimming pool, hot water, breakfast and rooms with verandas cleaned daily for Rp 100,000. And that's for two people. Try that in a youth hostel in Singapore, the U.S., Australia or just about anywhere else in the world and you will be laughed out of the building.
Are the complaints and demands of people based on the old adage, give them an inch and they'll' take a mile. Does Indonesia, in this visit Indonesia year, need to triple its prices to reflect the true value of its products and services, address head-on that old human habit of not trusting anything freely given? Or do visitors to the country need to learn some manners, drop their presumptions and prejudices that lead them by the nose into nasty little statements that question the integrity of the local people.
Certainly most visitors to Indonesia come with eyes and hearts open, and leave with these filled with new friendships, knowledge and respect. But for those little groups who sit self-satisfied with superiority in warungs comparing deals and rip-offs, think twice before you speak, your hosts, Indonesians, are listening.
-- Trisha Sertori
The Reader (not verified) — Mon, 04/07/2008 - 9:46am
You take foreigners to task but don't mention anything about all the rich Indonesians who hold similar or even worse views about the "lazy" poor people. For that matter, do you, who condemns these people so self-righteously, give to every beggar you see? It's foolishly naive to do so, when often they are forced to beg by criminal gangs who keep all their money. Eliminating this problem can't be helped by tossing a few rupiah at every cute little beggar you see. It takes collective action to solve these problems, but most well-off Indonesian people are largely content to ignore the problem or direct their complaints on "outsiders" rather than look at themselves and their own inaction.
You're right, there are a lot of rude inconsiderate foreigners. But if you think they, and not the corrupt, rich, complacent Indonesians who actually have the power to change the problems you speak of, are the problem, then you are the one who is smug and self-righteous. Try writing about the real problems in this country.
Scot MacKenzie (not verified) — Mon, 04/07/2008 - 8:28am
Trish,
Apologists like you are the reason that the status quo will never change in Indonesia.
Shame on you for writing this defeatist drivel and calling it informed opinion. I have evey right to sneer at the legacy of 30 years of corrupt Dictatorship over Indonesians by fellow Indonesians without making it personal.
I don't think that the taxi driver is to personally blame for his situation, nor the begging girl, but the people who ARE to blame and whose responsibility it is to fix these things are currently bursting their pants buttons in the DPR. Who put them there? Well, if you voted, you did Trish.
Looks like there's still a fair bit of "National Awakening" to do in the Jakarta Post editorial office.
Frank Harrison (not verified) — Sun, 04/06/2008 - 2:19pm
I cringe to read stories like this, because I can well imagine some Australians behaving in this manner. The underlying ethnocentric, "we-them" mentality is painfully apparent. Please be assured that many Australians - and I am sure New Zealanders, Americans and Europeans generally - would share your sentiments.
Since the end of the White Australia policy, this country has become one of the most multicultural nations on earth, and welcomes large numbers of international students and visitors. Take a walk through central Brisbane any day of the week for evidence.
Personal daily contact with people from other cultures at school, work, and university is inevitably having an impact on Australian attitudes. Prime Minister Rudd's recent apology to aboriginal Australians who were taken from their families for a "better" upbringing in European families is another hopeful sign.
F.H., Brisbane
Arif (not verified) — Sun, 04/06/2008 - 2:03pm
Indonesian people definitely deserve a better outlook in the media.
This country is more vibrant and culturally rich than the nearest Malaysia were tourism earns highest revenue. Unlike Malaysia, Indonesia is doing very less to promote tourism in this beautiful country. Indonesian tourism officials should work hard to promote the true image of Indonesia by working with independent media.
Indonesians are very cool people but lack English speak skills compared to Malaysians. This often lead to poor communication between visitors and their hosts.
Another negative factor is the lack of transparency in the public life which adversely affect the tourism sector too. As a tourist, I like to pay fixed charges than a bargained fare and it will help me to plan a trip with budget. To me, Blue Bird taxis are better than "Tarif Lama".
Such transparent practice in every sector will bring more confidence to public life and thus to the growth of tourism sector of Indonesia.
Indonesians civil movements should concentrate more to bring transparency in public life which will make solid changes in the current tourism scenario.