Today
Jakarta
- 25 °C
Other Publications
Muslim countries slam Dutch anti-Quran film at UN
The Associatd Press , Geneva | Wed, 04/16/2008 9:10 AM | World
Islamic countries used a meeting of the UN's top human rights body on Tuesday to demand the prosecution of a Dutch lawmaker whose anti-Quran movie has sparked Muslim protests.
Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, Indonesia and other members of the U.N. Human Rights Council said the Netherlands should adopt laws against religious defamation.
"We recommend to the government of the Netherlands that it must ... initiate prosecution against the author" of the movie "Fitna", Pakistan's representative Masood Khan told the 47-nation council.
The anti-Quran film by right-wing legislator Geert Wilders triggered angry street protests in Pakistan, Malaysia and Indonesia, and calls in other countries to boycott Dutch goods, when it was posted on a Web site last month.
In his film, Wilders couples verses from the Quran with images of the terror attacks on New York, Madrid and elsewhere, and shows footage of imams saying Islam should dominate the world.
The Dutch government has said it disagrees with the harsh, hateful tone of the film, but insists he has a constitutional right to air his views. The UN secretary-general and U.N. agencies have condemned the film. EU foreign ministers have sharply rejected its views.
Nebahat Albayrak of the Dutch delegation told council members that the public prosecutor is investigating whether the film breaks any laws.
Egypt criticized a recent ruling by a Dutch court that the views expressed by Wilders did not exceed the legal boundaries against inciting hatred or violence.
The Hague District Court last week said the lawmaker's right to free speech and role as a politician allow him to freely voice his criticisms of radical Islam and the Quran.
"This ruling may suggest that the judiciary is out of touch with the relevant international and regional obligations and jurisprudence in the field of human rights," said Omar Shalaby of the Egyptian delegation to the UN body.
Iran, which called the movie a "vivid example of Islamophobia and incitement to religious hatred," said the Netherlands should strengthen its rules against defamation of religions and Islamophobia. Iran is not a member of the council but can speak as an observer.
The Netherlands was among the first 16 countries to be examined during a two-week meeting of the council, which will be repeated three times a year until all 192 members of the United Nations have been scrutinized.
The council replaced the discredited Human Rights Commission two years ago. It has no enforcement powers, but is supposed to act as the world's moral conscience on human rights. (****)
More Web News
- Hungary's president to visit Indonesia
- Stop Jewish colonization: Seminar
- Hungary's president to visit Indonesia
- RI representative in NY hosts interfaith dialogue
- FOND FAREWELL
- UN body brainstorms future of colonized territories
- Pregnant woman pulled to safety after 50 hours in China earthquake rubble
- Myanmar allows Thai medical team to go to cyclone-hit delta
- Official death toll from China quake rises to 14,866
- Myanmar tells Thai PM cyclone situation under control, foreign experts not needed
Today's Paper
Weekender
Popular News
- Report: Malaysia's Mahathir urges Muslims to boycott Dutch products
- Media should promote Islam and democracy: Discussion
- Malaysia prime minister rejects calls to resign amid rare political turmoil
- Singapore bans films on terrorism, homosexuals, sex fetish
- Muslim countries slam Dutch anti-Quran film at UN
Classifieds
What's On
- Jakarta Furniture Fair
05/17/2008 - 05/25/2008, Jakarta Convention Centre - Palm Oil Summit & Plantation Supplies Expo 2008
05/21/2008 - 05/23/2008, Balai Sidang Jakarta Convention Centre - 32nd Annual IPA Exhibition
05/27/2008 - 05/29/2008, Jakarta Convention Centre
- ICRA 2008
06/18/2008 - 06/22/2008, Jakarta Convention Centre
Tahir Iqbal (not verified) — Thu, 05/15/2008 - 6:36am
It is not the first time that anti-Islamic forces have tried to agitate muslim sentiments. What we need to under stand is:
1.Why do they do this? Do they really hate Islam or they are paid individuals who are doing it because they know it is the easiest way to ignite muslim world. I consider it these are just ignorant individuals who are paid to do such silly actions (cartoons, films etc..) and should not be taken seriously other wise we Muslims will be fulfilling their evil designs of setting our own house on fire.
2. Should we retaliate? We should try to seek answer from the life of Holy Prophet (SAW). What he did when ignorant enemies tried to antagonise The Prophet (SAW). He ignored and prayed for them; we should do the same. It was this treatment of Prophet that converted the enemies to Islam.
3. However, at the govenrmental level there is a need to adapt a resolution at UN to protect sanctity of religions, religious figures and places of worship.
We can not stop perpetrators from doing such things. We must also remember that what we do to the feelings of others? Such as promoting hatred among various Mulism sects or hatred towards other religions and beliefs, was this ever encouraged or taught by Holy Prophet (SAW)? If we put our house in order and respect other faiths and other sects, the enemies of Isalm will surely get discouraged from doing such sinful acts.
May Allah give us wisdom and show us path of restraint which was taught by Holy Prophet (SAW).
TAHIR IQBAL
Chicago, IL
USA
Art (not verified) — Wed, 04/16/2008 - 5:53pm
Why does the Indonesian government make such loud noises over a private Internet film (Fitna) from The Netherlands while at the same time it is not protesting against hateful films from the Muslim-society???
http://www.memritv.org/clip/en/0/0/0/0/0/0/1739.htm