The Jakarta Post , Jakarta | Fri, 08/22/2008 10:37 AM | National
Hundreds of Christian theology students have been living in tents since a mob of angry Muslim neighbors stormed their campus last month wielding bamboo spears and hurling Molotov cocktails, according to reports by The Associated Press.
The incident comes amid growing concern that Indonesia's tradition of religious tolerance is under threat from Islamic hard-liners.
In talks since the attack, the Arastamar Evangelical School of Theology has reluctantly agreed to shut its 20-year-old campus in east Jakarta, accepting an offer this week to move to a small office building on the other side of the Indonesian capital.
"Why should we be forced from our house while our attackers can walk freely?" asked the Rev. Matheus Mangentang, chairman of the 1,400-student school.
The government of President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, which relies on the support of Islamic parties in Parliament, is struggling to balance deep Islamic traditions and a secular constitution. With elections coming next April, the government seems unwilling to defend religious minorities, lest it be portrayed as anti-Islamic in what is the world's most populous Muslim-majority country.
The July 25 attack, which injured 18 students, was the culmination of years of simmering tensions between the school and residents of the Kampung Pulo neighborhood.
Senny Manave, a spokesman for the Christian school, said complaints were received from neighbors about prayers and the singing of hymns, which they considered disturbing evangelical activity.
Several neighbors refused to comment, saying they feared that could further strain relations. A prominent banner, signed by scores of people, has been hung over an entrance to the neighborhood.
"We the community of Kampung Pulo demand the campus be closed and dissolved," it says.
The assault began around midnight, when students woke to the crash of stones falling on their dormitory roof as a voice over a loudspeaker at a nearby mosque cried "Allah Akbar," or "God is great" in Arabic.
The unidentified speaker urged residents to rise up against their "unwanted neighbors," said Sairin, the head of campus security, who goes by a single name.
The attack followed a claim that a student had broken into a resident's house, but police dismissed the charge.
Uneasy relations date to 2003, when neighbors began to protest the school's presence. Last year, residents set fire to shelters for construction workers to try to stop the campus from expanding deeper into the neighborhood. Some also questioned the legality of the school's permit.
Christian lawmaker Karol Daniel Kadang accused property speculators of provoking last month's incident to clear the land for more profitable use, after the school refused to sell out.
He also blamed the government for failing to build interfaith relations, which he and others believe are beginning to fray.
"People are still tolerant, but there is a growing suspicion among Muslims of others," said Prof. Franz Magnis-Suseno, a Jesuit priest who has lived in Indonesia for half a century.
He added that the police have failed to prevent both attacks on minorities and the forced closure of Christian churches and nontraditional mosques by mobs incited by radical Muslims.
"The state has some responsibility for this growing intolerance, namely by not upholding the law," he said.
A mob stormed a church service last Sunday in another east Jakarta neighborhood, forcing dozens of Christian worshipers to flee, said Jakarta Police Chief Col. Carlo Tewu. No arrests have been made.
Since being driven from campus, nearly 600 female students have been sleeping under suspended tarps at a nearby scout camp, where they had to dig trenches to keep water out during downpours. Classes are held with megaphones in the sweltering summer heat, under trees or the tarps. A similar number of male students live in a guesthouse. The remainder have returned to their families.
Food, water and school supplies are donated by church groups and community charities.
"We feel like refugees in our own country," said Dessy Nope, 19, a second-year student majoring in education. "How can you study here? I only followed 20 percent of my last lesson. It's difficult to concentrate."
Christians have not been the only targets for Muslim hard-liners, who this year set fire to mosques of a Muslim sect, Ahmadiyah, that they consider heretical.
In June, the government ordered members of the sect to return to mainstream Islam, sparking concern among activists who fear the state is interfering in matters of faith and caving in to the demands of radicals.
"We're living in a country where there are many religions, but the government cannot prevent the actions of fundamentalist groups," said Manave, the school spokesman. "The government cannot protect minorities." (amr)
Mohammad Ali (not verified) — Fri, 08/22/2008 - 11:17pm
In a time when Indonesia is promoting inter-faith talks around the world, it can't contain the hate of its own muslims citizens thowards other minorities, including fellow muslims from Ahmadiah. Mark my words. In 10 years, Indonesia will become a muslim nation, with muslim/syariah law, and it will crush rebelions from provincies of minorities like Bali, NTT, Ambon, Papua, Menado and even North Sumatra. By then, thousands or even millions of Indonesians Christians and Hindus will seek refuge abroad, because they will be prosecuted in their own land.
Rendra K (not verified) — Fri, 08/22/2008 - 9:26pm
Then you too, Iain should learn about Qur'an more too, and more objectively.
Sometime I wonder, how some moslem could made same misunderstanding about Qur'an with non-moslems.
I'll quote a translation from Al Qur'an, Surah al-An'am[6]: 108
Bismillahirrahmannirahim
"And don't you (moslems) slander what they (non-moslems) worship other than Allah. Because they (the non-moslems) will also slander Allah without limit and without knowledge."
Which is (funnily) exactly what happened at this very homepage.
Regarding the attack itself,I'd like to remind my fellow moslem to of Surah al-Anfal[8]: 61:
"And if the leaned to peace, then (you too) should lean to it (peace), and be tawakkal to Allah. Because Allah is All-Hearing, and All-Knowing."
Wallahua'lam
Armyn (not verified) — Fri, 08/22/2008 - 8:43pm
Once again, we face a big question to live as a nation.
Government, should be guardian of these pluralism. This body has to be more concern in this matter. Not just calculating distribution power regarding the power support in the House. President could be more elegantly represive, by stating such a "to the point" speech. Name the party that is out of the line. Warn them.
Society should also admit and realize that they live as a nation, avoid such feeling as a majority, life is not just preserving your own.
Why "you" have to act as God, while your self hasn't really do norms that you are believing in. Questioned that first, before act brutally.
Just believe, you will pay as big as you have done. Don't forget that!
Jon (not verified) — Fri, 08/22/2008 - 7:14pm
Intolerance has always mystified me. Just about all religions tout kindness towards others. It doesn't matter what version of "The Way" that you follow. When I read of instances of this type of activity, I definitely think that the offending individuals will have to account for themselves one day in front of their Maker. I suspect the outcome will not be as favorable as they hope for or have been lead to believe by thier extremist leaders. Typically, I feel that the extremist are sent from the other side to get the "easy sheep" lead away from the proper path. Otherwise, why would they be so concerned about the souls of others? It's not like their actions will "save" their targets souls and it certainly will not put them in favor with they Maker as they so radically try to convince thier sheep of...
Fools
Iain (not verified) — Fri, 08/22/2008 - 4:17pm
Ahmed, you need to study your Quran too. Because there are many parts that condone intolerance.
So, maybe these people are actually "good muslims" and following the instructions in the Quran and the examples of the the prophet in the Hadiths.
Robert juliono (not verified) — Fri, 08/22/2008 - 4:02pm
This is from the christian view over the incident, but why you don't try to view from the both side. You, even the Jakarta Post likely just highlight from the majority's action as well, from me all the christian in Indonesia have a streamline about the missionary, how to provoke, how to invite and how to converted to our community.
Trevor (not verified) — Fri, 08/22/2008 - 4:02pm
It seems that religious freedom is on a downward spiral in Indonesia.
Kunri — Fri, 08/22/2008 - 3:42pm
I fail to understand why a handful hard liners Muslims wants to force others to follow their interpretations of Islam and religion. Are they trying to prove that Islam is not a religion of peace and terrorist.
Rabin Dranir (not verified) — Fri, 08/22/2008 - 3:19pm
Radical Muslim should think FAR beyond their short-sighted n simple minded way of thinking. For years they've never been disturbed in any way regarding their beliefs, nor have been challenged every time the sound of azans being voiced from every single mosque in this country, didn’t even care whether the sound itself disturbing the neighborhood or not.
But hello, where's your respect? It's an education institution, for crying out loud. Please don't embarrass your fellow Muslim by doing stupid things. Remember, Indonesia is a Democracy Republic, not a particular-religion based Nation!
Keith harding (not verified) — Fri, 08/22/2008 - 1:48pm
Inondesia wake up !!! no Terorist in suits please.... The only good hard line fundamentalist is a dead one!