Aussie investors complain of fraud

Panca Nugraha ,  The Jakarta Post ,  Mataram   |  Fri, 11/28/2008 10:51 AM  |  The Archipelago

An Australian couple who had intended to develop a resort in West Lombok, West Nusa Tenggara, have been allegedly cheated out of Rp 4.2 billion (approximately US$380,000) by a local real estate agent.

Accompanied by their lawyer, Taufik Budiman, Paul Frederick Robson, 54, and Deborah Cynthia Strock, 52, lodged a report at the provincial police headquarters, hoping police would be able to resolve the case.

Taufik told reporters that his clients had bought 22 plots of land in Sekotong, West Lombok, with the intention of building a resort.

The land transaction was made through real estate agency PT TAP Mataram and the couple had transferred the money to its director, identified by the initials IBW, 36.

The couple had received land sale documents, issued by a notary public, from IBW, but when construction work was to begin, the pair became aware that the plots of land were still owned by local residents and had never been acquired by PT TAP.

"Our clients have paid PT TAP Rp 4.2 billion for the purchase of a total of 22 plots of land, but the locations were fraudulent as they are still owned by the villagers and could not be utilized," Taufik said.

Taufik's office filed a police report against the director of PT TAP, under the name of Deborah Cynthia Strock, at the end of September.

Taufik said his clients had been registered as foreign investors and held an investment license issued by the Investment Coordinating Board (BKPM), signed by deputy of investment services Achmadi Kurniadi, dated May 30, 2008.

Based on the document, PT Sea Shanty, owned by the Australians, would build 20 cottages in West Lombok's Sekotong resort area; an investment valued at $1 million.

"However, the project has stalled due to the sham. We hope police will be serious in handling the case because we have already been dealing with them for quite a long time," he said.

Besides Paul and Deborah Robson, PT TAP has also allegedly cheated another Australian investor, Anthony Stephen Hodgkinson, 50, through the same modus operandi.

Hodgkinson bought plots of property in seven locations in Sekotong, valued at Rp 2.4 billion, through PT TAP, but they too turned out to be fraudulent.

"We only realized it when we were driven out by the land owners when we were about to start construction. They said they had never sold the land to anyone. We also reported it to the police in August, but have not received a response as of now," said Guntur, an employee of PT Sunset Beach Villa, owned by Hodgkinson.

According to Guntur, investors placed their trust in PT TAP because it had been recommended by the provincial BKPM and West Lombok regent.

The Australian investors, alongside Taufik, went to the police headquarters to inquire about further developments on the cases on Wednesday. They gave testimony to investigators, but police have yet to name a suspect.

Meanwhile on Thursday, West Nusa Tenggara Police spokesman Comr. Tribudi Pangastuti verified that police had received the complaints from the Australians.

According to him, detectives are still investigating the cases and have gathered testimony from a number of witnesses.

"We certainly follow up every report we receive and hope the public can trust us. Investigations of the cases are still underway," Tribudi said.

Comments (27)  |   Post comment
A  |   A  |   A  |   Mail to a friend  |  Printer Friendly Version |  Digg it!  |  Add to Del.icio.us!  |  Add to Reddit!  |  Stumble it!   |  Share on facebook  

I agree with Lombok 32 these greedy money hungry people definatly should be deported back to Australia and the creep known as Paul Robson most definatly should be charged for his sick peadaphile dealings with innocent children.Be sent to lockup, not to return to Port Hedland.

the australians in this case came to indonesia, and lombok in specific, to steal and cheat the indonesian people and government.
they have been cought out and seen for what they are. fraudsters.
investing in indonesia is as safe as investing anywhere. if you do things legally and not try to steal, lie and cheat then investment is prosperous.
the 4 australians in this case thought they could come to indonesia and make money at the expense of a local businessman and indonesian government. how wrong they are and it's going to be an expensive lesson for them.
i think the indonesian government should be praised for showint these people for what they are..fruadsters, liars, and cheats.
no doubt when these 4 are deported to australia the extent of their cheating and lying will emerge through the media.
investment is needed and wanted in indonesia, however conmen can stay in australia where their business practices are welcomed and rewarded.

I see Mark is still ploughing on with his crusade....he is right about the land ownership issue, and just generally those two need their heads screwed on properly again.

First rule of land purchase (for foreigners only a lease in reality): first have a local lawyer look at the deal.
Second rule: only transfer money to a notary.

I AGREE WITH LOMBOK 32 THEIR IS MORE TO THIS STORY PERHAPS IT WIL COMETO LIGHT ABOUT THE SO CALLED INVESTORS OWING BILLIONS OF RUPIAH TO A LOAL COMPANY

it should be noted that there is definitely more to this story than what has appeared here.
the investors quoted are not exactly squeak clean themselves. one investor is in lombok because his personal activities with children are not legal in australia.
no doubt more will come out about that.

More stupid foreign lambs to the financial slaughter; when will they ever learn! Anyway, the story is flawed as it presumes as foreigners they can own land in Indonesia; they can not. If they alone own / control an investment company, it can not own land either, only lease. So how can they be defrauded out of something they can not legally own?

"but police have yet to name a suspect."

Love it. They know who took the money, they had a complaint made in September, and yet they still do not have a suspect.

Foreigners learn from this. This is not an isolated case. The RI is nothing but greed and trouble; keep clear.

What's On