With rare public emotion, George W. Bush
sat in judgment on his controversial, consequential presidency on
Monday, lamenting mistakes but claiming few as his own, heatedly
defending his record on disasters in Iraq and at home and offering
kindly advice to a successor who won largely because the nation ached
for something new.
By turns wistful, aggressive and joking in his final news conference, Bush covered a huge range of topics in summing up his eight years in the White House
— the latest in a recent string of efforts to have his say before
historians have theirs. Then the White House said he would do it again
Thursday night in a final address to the nation.
back to his first day in office, he recalled walking into the White
House and having "a moment" when he felt all the responsibilities of
the job landing on his shoulders. Barack Obama will feel that next week, he said, his tone gently understanding.
he was full of supportive words for Obama — the nation's first black
president — and talked of being deeply affected while watching people
say on television that they never thought they would see such a day,
many with "tears streaming down their cheeks when they said it."
Obama's election does speak volumes about how far this country has come
when it comes to racial relations," Bush said, seeming almost
He brushed off any
suggestion that he'd found the job of president too burdensome — or
that Obama would find it so. "It's just pathetic, isn't it, self-pity?"
he said. "And I don't believe that President-elect Obama will be full of self-pity."
the same time, Bush showed his skin is not so thick as all that.
"Sometimes the biggest disappointments will come from your so-called
friends," he advised Obama. Bush's former press secretary, Scott McClellan, released a scathing tell-all book last year that still stings around the West Wing.
Asked one last time by reporters about the major controversies of his presidency, Bush had a ready answer for each:
On the dismal economy he leaves behind for Obama, Bush said, "I
inherited a recession, I'm ending on a recession. In the meantime,
there were 52 months of uninterrupted job growth." The 2001 recession
began in March, two months into his presidency, but economists agree
the seeds were sown long before.
Bush also defended himself against economic attacks from his own party on the huge government bailout of Wall Street financial firms. He said, his voice rising, "If you were sitting there and heard that the depression could be greater than the Great Depression, I hope you would act, too, which I did."
On the five-year-old Iraq war, the issue that will define his
presidency, Bush said history will judge his actions but it is a fact
that violence diminished and everyday life became more stable after his
decision in 2007 to send an additional 30,000 American troops into the
• He vigorously took issue with critics of the federal response
to Katrina, the hurricane that devastated New Orleans. Gesturing and
speaking with feeling, he said, "Don't tell me the federal response was
slow when there were 30,000 people pulled off roofs right after the
storm passed," he said. "Has the reconstruction been perfect? No. Have
things happened fairly quickly? Absolutely."
• The president claimed progress toward peace in the Middle East, though any hopes for an accord soon have been dashed by, among other things, a bruising offensive by Israel in the Gaza Strip.
Most angrily, Bush dismissed "some of the elite" who say he has damaged
America's image around the world. "No question, parts of Europe have
said that we shouldn't have gone to war in Iraq without a mandate, but
those are few countries," he said.
The president's actions after the Sept. 11 attacks — such as establishing the prison for suspected terrorists at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba,
approving tough interrogation methods that some say amount to torture
and instituting information-gathering efforts at home decried by civil rights groups — were compounded by global outrage at the 2003 invasion of Iraq, particularly later when the alleged weapons of mass destruction that were the main justification for war turned out not to exist.
"In terms of the decisions that I had made to protect the homeland, I wouldn't worry about popularity," he said.
Asked about mistakes, Bush cited a few that he preferred to term "disappointments" — not finding those weapons of mass destruction in Iraq, the abuses committed by members of the U.S. military at the Abu Ghraib detention center in Iraq, giving a speech two months after the start of the Iraq war under a "Mission Accomplished" banner on an aircraft carrier, Congress' failure to pass free-trade agreements with Colombia, Panama and South Korea, and the negative tone in Washington that belied his 2000 campaign promise to be a "uniter not a divider."
he offered no evidence he takes personal responsibility for any of
those failures. The only two areas where he seemed to acknowledge that
errors in judgment had been his were his penchant for cowboy rhetoric,
such as saying "Bring 'em on!" to foes in Iraq, and his decision to
pursue partial privatization of Social Security immediately after his 2004 re-election.
He said arguing for immigration reform would have been a better use of the political capital he earned through his victory, in part because lawmakers were not yet convinced that Social Security presented an imminent crisis. Over two years of intensive efforts, Bush achieved reform in neither area.
Bush, who watched a Republican drubbing last fall, gave his party
advice about how to rise from the ashes. Referring back to the divisive
immigration debate, in which conservatives blocked broad changes and
raised concern that illegal immigrants would be given amnesty, Bush
said the image of his party that resulted was "Republicans don't like
"This party will come back. But the party's message has got to
be that different points of view are included in the party," he said.
Bush began what he termed "the ultimate exit interview" Monday
with a lengthy and gracious thank-you to his core of usual reporters,
calling many by name and saying he respects their work even if he often
dislikes the product.
Looking to his first day out of office, Bush appeared somewhat
flummoxed but also relieved at the prospect of waking up at his Texas
ranch next Wednesday with, by his own admission, little idea what to do
beyond bringing coffee to his wife.
Monday's news conference
offered only one bit of news, and — in these times when Bush has seemed
to fade from office a little more each day — even that was overtaken by
He said he would ask Congress to release the remaining $350 billion in Wall Street bailout
money if Obama wants him to — but that Obama had not yet asked. A mere
two hours later, Obama had made his request to Bush, and the White
House said the president had agreed.