TheJakartaPost

Please Update your browser

Your browser is out of date, and may not be compatible with our website. A list of the most popular web browsers can be found below.
Just click on the icons to get to the download page.

Jakarta Post

Guns, butter and democracy

The recent crash of the Air Force Fokker-27 in Bandung has triggered yet another alarm to the authorities on the state of our military power

Nurkholisoh Ibnu Aman (The Jakarta Post)
Surabaya
Fri, April 17, 2009

Share This Article

Change Size

Guns, butter and democracy

The recent crash of the Air Force Fokker-27 in Bandung has triggered yet another alarm to the authorities on the state of our military power. While many argue that the crash was caused by bad weather, one cannot deny the fact that most of our military equipment is in a worrying state. The ill-fated F-27 itself was manufactured in 1976, and was one of seven F-27s still in use by the military.

Once considered the strongest in Southeast Asia, the Indonesian Air Force is now suffering from aging war machines and underfunding. A number of military air accidents over the past few years have been linked to the un-airworthiness of our jet fighters. Anecdote has it that more soldiers are killed in accidents than in battle.

But a similar scenario is currently affecting the Army and Navy too, only they are less visible than problems in the Air Force. Accidents involving army tanks or navy ships are less likely to appear in newspapers headlines.

Currently, Indonesia invests less than 1 percent of its GDP on defense, less than our neighbors like Singapore (5 percent) or Malaysia (3 percent). This figure is even more pronounced when noting that Singapore and Malaysia actually have fewer islands and citizens to protect.

Our defense budget for 2009 is Rp 35.03 trillion (US$ 3 billion), a far cry from the ideal Rp 100 trillion the Defense Ministry requested. Things are getting worse too, given that the 2009 budget is less than what was allocated in 2008. With the bulk of its budget going to soldiers' salaries, the modernization of military equipment is a luxury we cannot afford.

Since the Asian economic crisis of 1997, our financial resources have been devoted mainly to servicing a mountain of debts, and to funding various economic recovery programs. The armed forces (TNI) has had to accept their low priority in the national agenda.

The most the TNI has been able to do is increase its efficiency, but this situation has resulted in the deterioration of functioning equipment and the force's combat readiness. Recent analysis estimates that only around 42 percent of our military aircraft are airworthy.

On the other hand, we have seen a tremendous increase in funding allocated toward developing democracy over the past few years. Vice President Jusuf Kalla himself has voiced concerns over the staggering cost of running a democracy in Indonesia. With our 465 municipalities and 33 provinces, Indonesia is conducting roughly 100 elections every year - or 1 election every 3 days. It is estimated that around Rp 50 trillion of the state budget is spent on these direct elections annually.

At this point, we need to remind our politicians that military power is essential to maintaining our country's dignity. An increasing number of territorial disputes with neighboring countries is evidence hard to ignore. It is a sad truth that we are seen as powerless in defending our own territory.

To increase the defense budget is, however, not an easy task. Politicians are by nature more inclined to support popular programs such as education or health care. Through such programs, they hope to win public votes and thus ensure their re-election.

There is also a psychological thing about defense affairs. In the minds of most people, it is not seen as something imminent. The idea of us getting into a war seems distant and very slim. Some even argue that our defense budget is a waste of money.

The truth is that defense affairs have implications far beyond defending ourselves in times of war. A strong military power helps us to earn respect from other countries in international relationships and thus empowers our diplomatic muscle. It may also provide us with a "deterring effect" that we need to maintain peace.

As the old adage says si vis pacem para bellum, meaning that those who wish for peace must be prepared for war.

The writer is an activist at TANDEF, an non-profit organization that aims to promote defense awareness among Indonesians.

Your Opinion Matters

Share your experiences, suggestions, and any issues you've encountered on The Jakarta Post. We're here to listen.

Enter at least 30 characters
0 / 30

Thank You

Thank you for sharing your thoughts. We appreciate your feedback.