Indah Setiawati , The Jakarta Post , Jakarta | Fri, 11/06/2009 11:37 AM | City
Jakartans will have to suffer a series of black outs indefinitely after the state electricity company PT PLN announced that it is facing budget constraints to procure new transformers to help ease the capacity overload.
Nur Pamudji, PLN’s general manager of the Java-Bali load control center and distribution, said Thursday that his office had planned a project worth Rp 5.6 trillion (US$583.3 million) to strengthen the city’s electricity by 2012.
“The project was initiated in 2006, but we have made little progress due to funding constraints,” he said during a workshop about the Cawang powerhouse in East Jakarta on Thursday.
He said the company could only spare Rp 800 billion from its budget, or 14 percent of the estimated
cost, leaving a mammoth Rp 4.8 trillion deficit.
“We are still seeking other sources of funding, including from export loans, the state budget and the World Bank,” Nur said, adding the company had just asked for permission from the government to look for Rp 3 trillion from export loans.
He said the projects included the procurement of eight power transformers, and the enhancement
and looping of the 150-kilovolt capacity network.
The eight transformers, which cost Rp 200 billion each, would be installed to fortify existing transformers in some powerhouses, including Bekasi, Balaraja in Tangerang, Muara Tawar in Bekasi, Gandul in South Jakarta, Kembangan in West Jakarta and Cawang.
“The transformer procurement for Gandul is set to be complete by the end of 2010,” Nur said.
He said the installment of two transformers for Balaraja was scheduled to be finished by mid-2011.
Only when the project is completed in 2012, will Jakarta be safe from any blackouts, he claimed.
Large swathes of Greater Jakarta suffered blackouts that lasted from Monday night until Tuesday evening because of lingering trouble at the Muara Karang and Gandul powerhouses.
The load in most city powerhouses was under pressure following the exploding transformer at the Cawang powerhouse on Sept. 29.
The Agency for Assessment and Application of Technology (BPPT), which is in charge of the investigation of the incident, announced the blast was triggered by dielectric losses and thermal instability in the transformer.
“The explosion was caused by the transformer’s continuous and long exposure to high temperatures
due to an overloading of the Cawang powerhouse, which reached over 90 percent of capacity,” said Hamzah Hilal, a senior researcher in the agency.
He said Cawang powerhouse, which currently had two transformers, should acquire an additional two transformers to be used to share the load burden and for backup.
“The safe load burden is 60 percent of the transformer capacity.”
Nur also said that black outs were inevitable with the limited number of transformers available to share the load.
City transformers had to shoulder up to 90 percent of its load capacity recently, higher than PLN’s safety standard of 85 percent.
According to Nur, electricity demand in the city has risen by 5 percent annually.
Razique (not verified), Crossroad — Thu, 11/26/2009 - 3:26am
I'm involved in power project development ie; developing Financial Model to formulate a reasonable tariff which in the end must be cost effective and sustainable. Not many really understand what it takes to develop a power project right from the issue of fuel supply to generating electricity to be transmitted via transmission line and in the end to be distributed to the consumers . The issue of power shortages in Indonesia and frequent blackouts does not rest on the generation side alone, it is the whole picture. Meaning the generation, trasmission and distribution sector that must be planned and developed concurrently. Apart from that, the most critical issue here is the fuel source itself, if the fuel source can be managed at a reasonable price, then the whole process can be worked out to formulate an economical tariff pricing (how much it cost per kWhr). In the end, the main subject matter to be addressed here is, if we want to develop something or anything for that matter, AT WHAT COST? It all comes down to numbers. When it comes to financing any project (especially under project financing exercise), the bankers will decide who and what they wants to finance. In order to do that, there must be a bankable proposal in terms of commercial and technical offtake. The bankers will definitely appoint an independent checking engineer (ICE)to verify the techno commercial parameters that will be scrutinised time and time again in order to ensure that economically the project is feasible and viable. Indonesia or any country for that matter will always have a "what i called the 10% problem" (which is very2 conservative anyway). Thats the 5% growth on demand and 5% derating factor. In a nutshell, the issue of stable and reliable electricity supply will consequently affect whatever GDP forecast made by the government. This in the end will be translated into income per capita. I can only voice out my opinion, but the decision lies with the powers that be.Lianto Osa (not verified), Jakarta — Wed, 11/18/2009 - 10:36pm
Yayan, you must be joking. Don't use Los Banos as a benchmark, use Los Angeles!!! See other developed countries, learn from them and grow.Henrymanoe (not verified), Kupang — Fri, 11/13/2009 - 11:22am
East of Java has had blackouts for years. These hardly made headlines; not even in local newspapers as the phenomena is no longer news. Now Jakarta experiences blackouts the truth hits home that PLN is a poorly managed, ill equipped, cash-strapped and corrupt government-owned company. Competition should help, but that will still leave most of Indonesia in the dark for quite a while to come. Sell PLN to an international power company with a good track record.Yayan (not verified), los Banos, Philipines — Thu, 11/12/2009 - 10:43am
I have experence, here, in Los Banos, It is worst here every sunday we have black out, They reasoned why it happened cause they should maintenance and every time we had strong wind it will blackout againt So look at bright side what PLN said may be it is correct cause i have noticed also in Indonesia I only paid around 50.000 ruipah per month. Here even we doing saving electricity it would be paid equal to 250.000. It is nice to live in Indonesia my friendsKungpang (not verified), Semarang — Thu, 11/12/2009 - 8:00am
Agree!! It's weird a monopolist is short of money when people have no other choices to buy electricity. And with huge subsidy from the Govt, I have nothing but wonder where all those money gone. I mean to whose pocket??? Uhh, my beloved Indonesia when will you move forward??Denni hooping (not verified), jakarta — Wed, 11/11/2009 - 1:19am
I first came to Indonesia 30 plus years ago and the situation is worse today than then. Just to see the web of cables that are strung along every road in major cities is a joke, they perfectly mirror the chaos and standards within PLN. I think everybody is of the same opinion, complete managerial incompetence and misuse of revenue are the root causes. Apart from creating immense suffering to individual citizens, the incalculable loss to business caused by the idiots that run PLN is a crime. Sack the lot of them and get in honest, professional management.Jon (not verified), US — Tue, 11/10/2009 - 11:52pm
Nice one Jimmy!! Perusahan Lilin Negara....haha Those selling candles must have bribed those in PLN. More black outs = More lilin sold!!Anon (not verified), Anon — Tue, 11/10/2009 - 1:32pm
I lived and worked in Jakarta in 1993 to 1994 with PLN on several IPP and transmission projects (coal fired, pumped storage, 500 kV reinforcement), and the forecast load demand was tremendous in those times. Corruption in state agencies then was a huge issue and it seems there has been some improvement. I'm not sure what system planning standard is followed by PLN these days, but good luck, you may need it going forward.Lianto Osa (not verified), Jakarta — Mon, 11/09/2009 - 11:04pm
I studied and worked in Tokyo from 1987 - 1999 and did not experience any single blackout there. How come Jakarta still has this problem in 2009??? Welcome to the stone age.Shinakuma (not verified), Jakarta — Mon, 11/09/2009 - 11:02pm
As a customer of PLN, I do not need to know what their problem is. All I need to know is that my house is powered. Today my area was was hit TWICE without power! A total of 10hrs+ without electricity! That was unacceptable in my point of view. I truly don't understand what their problem is. PLN is the only company in Indonesia that sells electricity (MONOPLOY) to Indonesians, and yet they claim that they do not have enough money to repair/maintain and buy their things!?! I have not heard of a company given a monopoly that have lost money or run out of cash. That is crazy. This is pure corruption in Plain Sight. I am wondering when Indonesians will start to sue PLN. PLEASE open up the market so other companies can come in and compete to provide a better service for all.