Jakarta, ID
Monday, May 28 2012, 18:37 PM

Opinion

Text your say: Moving the capital city

A- A A+

Your comments about the idea to move the capital city as revived by President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, from overburdened Jakarta to elsewhere in this country.

 

Why should the government have its own brand new city? This is a typical example of a government that views itself as more important than the people it is supposed to serve.

It is also an admission of failure by this government that cannot seem to bring about any improvement in the quality of living in the cities and elsewhere.

A new government city would drain financial resources that should be spent on educating the idiots who voiced their support in this newspaper for this idea. It’ll be another corruption-infested mismanaged fiasco.

Diederik
Jakarta

 
I totally agree to move the official seat of government to the area such as Jonggol or Sentul, in which Jakarta is still the capital city of Indonesia.

It would be like Den Haag and Amsterdam in the Netherlands. In terms of budget, it is not realistic to move the official seat of government outside the Java Island.

The distance between Jonggol/Sentul (as a new government seat) and Jakarta, as a financial hub of the country, will be on par compared to what other countries have experienced long before Indonesia, namely Australia, the United States, Malaysia and the Netherlands. Jakarta will be fine, not lose its charm and could organize itself much better with new infrastructure.

If doing so, I expect Jonggol/Sentul to have a fresh start (like Putrajaya, Washington DC, Den Haag) in which the central Government is going to build it with better design, well-planned infrastructure (subway/tram, train, buses, roads, highways, sidewalks), beautiful parks, rivers. It will represent Indonesia to the world for the next century. Let the central Government  realize this beautiful vision.

Krido
Jakarta


Personally, I think the money involved in building a new capital could as easily be spent putting in better infrastructure in Jakarta. Otherwise, in the future all the energy and funding will go into the new capital and Jakarta will become a “black hole of Calcutta” which would be a great shame for such a vibrant place.

Evah N
Canberra

 

Don’t try to move Jakarta even in your dreams. Jakarta’s location is the most strategic and secure. Jakarta is covered and surrounded from earthquakes, tsunami and enemy attacks.

If we move to the capital to Padang, Yogya or Maluku there will be the danger of tsunami and earthquakes. If we move to Kalimantan or Papua or Sulawesi, the capital will be closer to enemy combatants and missiles.

Maman Sudarmaji
Jakarta