Karzai call for end to night raids irks US general
Deb Riechmann, The Associated Press, Kabul | Mon, 11/15/2010 8:23 PM
Top U.S. commander in Afghanistan, Gen. David Petraeus, was frustrated
by the Afghan president's blunt call for a reduced military footprint in
the country - a remark that threatened to undermine effortto maintain
international support for the war at this week's NATO summit.
President Hamid Karzai said in an interview this week that he wanted the
coalition to put an end to night raids, which cause friction between
Afghans and foreign troops. The operations are a key part in Petraeus'
strategy to rout insurgents, improve security and bolster governance and
development.
Karzai's spokesman, Waheed Omar, downplayed the president's comments and
said he did not think they would affect a NATO conference where
attendees will discuss the way Afghan secuty forces will take the lead
in defending and protecting the nation by 2014.
NATO and diplomatic officials said Monday that Petraeus was annoyed by
Karzai's remarks, which came just days before the NATO summit starts
Friday in Lisbon, Portugal. They said NATO had received assurances that
Karzai was on-board with the coalition's strategy and that international
forces were working hard to address some of his concerns.
Support for the war is waning in the capitals of troop-contributing
nations and NATO officials hope to use the Lisbon summit to convince
heads of state that progress is being made, and that the effort warrants
continued support.
Omar said the president has confidence in Gen. Petraeus.
"The president has once again made it clear that this is not a critique
of the overall strategy," Omar said. "But this is a reflection of a
mature partnership whereby partners are confident and partners take the
liberty to express their views as to how certain things within the over
strategy could improve."
In an interview with The Washington Post, Karzai said the time has come
to reduce military operations and the "intrusiveness into the daily
Afghan life."
He said he wants American troops off the roads and out of Afghan homes
and that the long-term presence of so many foreign soldiers will only
make the war worse. Karzai's remarks come just as more than 30,000 U.S.
reinforcements have all arrived and are pushing hard against Taliban
strongholds especially in the south and east.
Karzai also said the U.S. should end the rising number of Special
Operations forces night raids that aggravate Afghans and could
strengthen the Taliban insurgency.
"I don't like it in any manner and the Afghan people don't like these
raids in any manner," Karzai said. "We don't like raids in our homes.
This is a problem between us and I hope this ends as soon as possible.
... Terrorism is not invading Afghan homes and fighting terrorism is not
being intrusive in the daily Afghan life."
Karzai's remarks surprised a U.S. lawmaker in Washington who visited Karzai last week.
"I'm just stunned," U.S. Sen. Lindsey Graham, a Republican from South
Carolina, told ABC's "This Week" on Sunday. "To take the night raids off
the table would be a disaster."
Graham said he met Karzai as part of a congressional delegation that
visited Afghanistan last week and the president never raised the issue
of night raids.
Graham said Petraeus must be allowed to continue with his
counterinsurgency strategy. "We own the night militarily, and are making
a huge impact on the Taliban, the insurgency as a whole," he said.
A senior official with the coalition said the NATO raids, which have
increased six-fold in the past 18 months, are conducted in full
partnership with Afghan troops.
The official, who spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss Karzai's
remarks, said that the coalition shares Karzai's concerns about the
operations. But he said that precision operations against high-value
insurgents and their networks remained a key component of NATO's
comprehensive civilian-military counterinsurgency operations.
Omar also said Monday that the disbanding of security companies that
escort NATO convoys will take part in two stages - suggesting these
companies will likely be allowed to stay past a Dec. 17 deadline that
Karzai had decreed for their dissolving
The decree raised cries of alarm among the many companies and officials
who employ armed guards as escorts and to guard compounds, along with
NATO, which uses them to guard supply convoys.
The Afghan government has estimated that there are between 30,000 and
40,000 armed security guards working in the country in 52 licensed
security firms. About 26,000 of them work for the U.S. government,
mostly as military escorts, according to U.S. officials.
Omar said that convoy security companies will fall under the Interior
Ministry in the first stage of the transition. Then, once a police
battalion has been trained for the task of guarding convoys, it will
replace these companies. Omar did not provide a timeline for this
transition, saying that details would be available after the Muslim
holiday of Eid al-Adha.
Separately, NATO said Monday that another two service members died in an
insurgent attack in eastern Afghanistan the previous day, raising the
toll of those killed in the single incident to five. The deaths bring to
33 the number of coalition service members who have died in Afghanistan
so far this month. In another attack, an insurgent rocket sparked a
huge blaze inside an American base.
NATO did not provide details on Sunday's attack or the nationalities of
the service members. Though a number of nations have troops in the east,
the majority of the forces are American.
In eastern Kunar province on Monday, an insurgent rocket struck inside a
U.S. base near the provincial capital of Asadabad, sparking a blaze
that destroyed six armored vehicles and an ambulance, NATO and Afghan
officials said.
Associated Press Television News video showed plumes of black smoke
rising from inside Camp Wright through much of the morning, with flames
shooting up into the air. Provincial police chief Khalilullah Zaiyi said
Afghan firefighters were dispatched to help quell the blaze.
Taliban spokesman Zabiullah Mujahid claimed responsibility for the attack.
The base came under attack from gunfire and rockets early in the morning
and one rocket hit a fuel container, starting the fire, NATO said.
There were no coalition injuries and the fire was contained by late
morning. The six armored vehicles destroyed were Mine Resistant
Ambush-Protected vehicles known as MRAPS, which can cost as much as $1
million each.