Jakarta, ID
Tuesday, May 29 2012, 08:20 AM

Readers Forum

Letter: RI-Malaysia’s cultural disputes

A- A A+

The author of “RI-Malaysia relations: All in the family” (The Jakarta Post, Dec. 30) had a half-blinkered approach.

“Malaysia’s progressive appropriation of Indonesian traditional properties and songs” is an example.

How could you say appropriation of properties and songs when in the same breath you mentioned “people with such close, common roots”.

The fact, which is clear to everyone else outside Indonesia, is that nobody is “claiming cultural superiority” over Indonesians. Rather, Malaysia is just claiming what is ours, which is as much as yours, too, anyway.

Your article tried to be objective, which is rather noble I would say, but at the same time succeeded only in clouding the issue further. Over here what we understand is a lot of the strain in relations is due to your media highlighting the negative issues in order to sell a few more papers and neglecting the negative impact it might have on relations with your “good siblings and neighbors”.

As a Malaysian, I have seen a lot of my Indonesian friends lead successful lives in Malaysia.

Indonesia has a huge population and its territory is huge. As Ita Yulianto said, the poor folk from distant provinces are sometime the target of discrimination. But let us sit back and think. Who were the culprits that dragged them out in the very first place? Are these people are true patriots?

As a Malaysian, I have seen our authorities deal with hundreds of thousands of people still in the country with expired visas or passports. Generally, as Malaysians, we have a fair attitude toward any other human from any part of the world.

The government had to offer a “pardon scheme” to allow my fellow Indonesian friends to exit the country and re-register.

I just want my Indonesian friends to understand that, as brothers and sisters in Southeast Asia. We need to respect our own home from our parents to our siblings. In turn we’ll show respect to our relatives. This will reflect the “roots” that we share.

Let’s think of a better way to improve our society. A good society will increase wealth or culture in both nations.

We need to look after and talk in a proper diplomatic manner. I would like to see this to happen in our region within the next decade so that no one in the world will notice that we came from common roots millions of years ago.


Aje Me
Kuala Lumpur