TheJakartaPost

Please Update your browser

Your browser is out of date, and may not be compatible with our website. A list of the most popular web browsers can be found below.
Just click on the icons to get to the download page.

Jakarta Post

Asians are highly respectful of officials, which is a bad idea

Officials in uniform stopped reader Janakan Arulkumarasan outside the door of a shopping mall, saying: “Excuse me, Sir

Nury Vittachi (The Jakarta Post)
Bangkok
Sun, January 5, 2014

Share This Article

Change Size

Asians are highly respectful of officials, which is a bad idea

O

fficials in uniform stopped reader Janakan Arulkumarasan outside the door of a shopping mall, saying: '€œExcuse me, Sir. We are checking random bags because of a significant terrorism threat.'€ Janakan obediently handed over his bags. '€œWould you mind removing your shoes, Sir?'€ He took off his shoes. '€œPlease walk around this pole, Sir.'€ He circumnavigated the pole. '€œWould you mind jumping up and down, Sir?'€ He pogoed. As further exercises were requested, a crowd began to form outside the mall in Croydon, UK.

Janakan finally asked to see some ID. The man burst out laughing and told him they were being filmed by a hidden camera for a show about how far people will go without questioning authority. Janakan, a Sri Lankan who works in Hong Kong, told me: '€œApparently I had gone well beyond anything anyone else had done, or they had scripted, so he was improvising.'€

Of course, people say Asians are more compliant to authority figures than Westerners. This is utter rubbish, unless whoever is reading this is wearing a uniform, in which case I agree 100 percent, Sir. Yet the weird thing is that Asian officials so rarely deserve respect.

For example, officials in a city in southern China recently sent phone text messages to residents offering them taxpayer cash to take part in a survey, the China Daily reported. Residents were annoyed, complaining that they had been told to write positive comments, and '€” this was the really irritating bit '€” they were being bribed with their own money.

At roughly the same time, another demonstration of the '€œvalues'€ of officials took place in Thailand.

Transport Minister Chadchart Sittipunt instructed officials to keep in touch with the needs of the masses by using the public bus system. A few days later a reporter from The Nation newspaper saw him standing at a bus stop.

The minister waited. And waited. And then phoned his chauffeur to pick him up in a limousine, the paper said. '€œThe system'€™s totally screwed up, who runs it? Oh, it'€™s me,'€ the official remarked. Well, no, he didn'€™t say that, but he should have done.

In Japan, the obsession with cuteness makes it hard for officials to generate respect. The Japanese prison service recently decided to '€œexpress its personality'€ by launching a giant cuddly toy mascot.

A human-sized version with an actor inside prances around at prison-related functions. Instead of convicted murderers being dragged off by burly guards, I picture them holding the hand of a giant cuddly toy speaking in a high-pitched voice: '€œHello! You'€™re going to come and live with me from now on, sweetie!'€ Critics say it is '€œsending the wrong message'€ about crime and punishment.

To balance out the cuddliness of the prison service, shopkeepers in Japan are super-tough, and have been fighting a spate of shoplifting incidents by putting up signs saying that anyone caught will be killed. One sign spotted by a Rocketnews24 reporter simply said: '€œShoplifters beware. The owner is a rampant homosexual.'€ No further details were provided, leaving the actual punishment to the imagination.

If a Japanese shopkeeper tells me to jump up and down, I'€™m just going to do it.

The writer is a columnist and journalist.

Your Opinion Matters

Share your experiences, suggestions, and any issues you've encountered on The Jakarta Post. We're here to listen.

Enter at least 30 characters
0 / 30

Thank You

Thank you for sharing your thoughts. We appreciate your feedback.