TheJakartaPost

Please Update your browser

Your browser is out of date, and may not be compatible with our website. A list of the most popular web browsers can be found below.
Just click on the icons to get to the download page.

Jakarta Post

The difference between humans and animals is that dogs are smart

I’ve always told my children that they can turn traffic lights green using only their minds

Nury Vittachi (The Jakarta Post)
Bangkok
Sun, June 15, 2014

Share This Article

Change Size

The difference between humans and animals is that dogs are smart

I

'€™ve always told my children that they can turn traffic lights green using only their minds. My wife scolds me, but it totally works. You just have to choose the moment you start thinking really carefully.

The difference between human abilities and those of lesser creatures fascinates me. Which is why I was shocked when a reader forwarded me an Indian government minister'€™s statement that dolphins'€™ high intelligence indicates they '€œshould be seen as non-human persons'€.

If the definition of being a person is linked to intelligence, three-quarters of the people on my morning commuter bus would rate a classification roughly level with chickens [no offense intended to chickens].

These folk carry electronic devices that can instantly access humanity'€™s greatest works, but use them solely for screen-pecking games so repetitive they would bore a moderately bright patch of toe-fungus to tears.

Campaigns calling for humans and animals to be treated equally are growing in North America, Europe and Australia, but India is ahead of the game. A dog was hit with criminal charges for biting a retired police officer in Lucknow in February, and last year, three goats were detained for damaging a Chennai police car. In Nigeria, police famously detained a goat on suspicion of attempting to steal a Mazda 323. That didn'€™t ring true with me: Goats are canny outdoor types and would surely opt for the open-top Mazda MX-5.

Humans also come in a wide range of intelligence levels, as was made clear by a story sent in by reader Wendy Tong. A motorist named Carmen, 34, was arrested for being drunk in charge of a vehicle, it said. Police in the US state of New Jersey told her to call a friend to drive her home. She phoned her buddy Nina, 23, who arrived in a similar state and was also arrested. So they both called a third friend, Ryan, 33, who drove up looking extremely wobbly and was also detained. The news report doesn'€™t say what happened next, but one hopes officers kept the system going until they arrested everyone in the city, state or country.

Wendy said drunkenness was not normally funny, but this report made her laugh. Agreed. Wendy, your tale reminded me of the first time I heard the song about the old woman who swallowed a fly and then swallowed a spider to catch the fly and ultimately a bird, cat, dog, and cow. I was only six but already had a skeptic'€™s need for proof. '€œYou got photos?'€ I asked the kindie teacher. She shifted nervously in her seat, and I'€™ve been suspicious of teachers ever since.

Outside Asia and Africa, animal arrests are rare. For example, several '€œstoner'€ dogs were recently found to have become addicted to the highs you get by licking cane toads in Queensland, Australia, but not one was charged with substance abuse. The permissiveness of Western societies horrifies me.

Animals and humans should be treated the same. Although I did struggle to teach my dog to change the color of traffic lights using mind-control. In the end, I just let her bark at the lights until they turned green, which seemed to work just as well.

The writer is a columnist and journalist.

Your Opinion Matters

Share your experiences, suggestions, and any issues you've encountered on The Jakarta Post. We're here to listen.

Enter at least 30 characters
0 / 30

Thank You

Thank you for sharing your thoughts. We appreciate your feedback.