Hazeonomics: Seeing through the smoke
Joseph Cherian, Jack Loo and Ang Swee Hoon
The Jakarta Post
And so, the haze is back in the news. Containing the haze has become a cyclical problem. It usually starts off with complaints of the lack of firefighting resources, followed by rejections of offers to help.
Accusations fly of parties responsible for starting the fires. More often than not, it ends with the announcement of a regional joint agreement to fight haze. Yet, when the haze is blown away, the political will to follow through dissipates. And the cycle resumes when the haze returns the following year.
Although ASEAN has taken some steps, it has been largely ineffective in ensuring that the haze does not recur.
Two years have passed since ASEAN adopted a joint monitoring system for locating fire hotspots, but what remains is an empty shell with governments reluctant to share map data. ASEAN took 11 long years to get Indonesia to sign the transboundary haze treaty, a comprehensive action plan that was signed by the other nations in 2003. That is more than a decade's worth of time that could have been spent on developing resources to combat haze.
Whatever the culpability of the planters, plantations or governments, the priority is to put out the fire and deal with everything else later. The economic cost of not doing so is high, and containing the fire isn't cheap.
In the US, it costs about S$20 million (US$14.3 million) of firefighting equipment, resources and professionals to fight a 3,000 hectare wildfire, the same size as the land burned by the Riau blaze, which caused the infamous 2013 haze in Malaysia and Singapore. This includes support professionals (such as smokejumpers and firefighters), sensor-equipped early-warning aircraft directing aerial and ground-based firefighting efforts, and air tankers that can unleash water and fire retardants.
If ASEAN does not have these critically needed assets to fight its perennial wildfires, its three most affected members ' Malaysia, Indonesia and Singapore ' should start acquiring them.
If costs are a concern, instead of an outright purchase, perhaps leasing options from countries such as the US may be explored.
The formation of a regional joint fire brigade is needed to put out the fire. The training, staffing and maintenance of that brigade can be shared by the multiple agencies involved in fighting fires in these countries.
Assistance can also be provided by wealthy donor countries and organizations interested in protecting the environment. Any tri-country firefighting exercise will need both Malaysia's and Singapore's resources and support, along with Indonesia's consent ' the good news is that this has been done before.
'Operation Haze' in September 1997 was the biggest cross-border firefighting mission in history. It involved teams of Malaysian and Indonesian fire fighters battling haze-causing fires in Sumatra and Kalimantan.
Apart from the aforementioned firefighting equipment and fire brigade, it will take a combination of enforceable legislation and political will that ASEAN can adopt to eliminate haze.
Professor Ivan Png from the National University of Singapore Business School has highlighted that international law has provisions for transboundary environmental and criminal liability.
The Transboundary Haze Pollution Act in Singapore allows entities causing or contributing to unhealthy levels of haze in the island state to be fined up to S$2 million. This means that Singapore can prosecute its plantation owners who commit arson outside the country.
Following this and taking a leaf from the UN Convention on Long-range Transboundary Air Pollution, where government negotiations are focused on collective problem solving, ASEAN can take a bold move by mooting a common set of laws that address the region's interests in the environment and general well-being. Violators can be referred to an EU-style ASEAN Court of Justice.
It has also been suggested that a plantation agency equivalent to the successful Oil Spill Response Limited agency be formed, whose responsibility will be to respond effectively to wildfires on plantation land wherever they may occur.
This way, the various regional government agencies and industry players, such as this plantation-owned firefighting cooperative, can form a transboundary force to fight plantation fires.
Given that most commercial plantations, despite their denials, prefer to use fire ('slash and burn') for cost-related reasons and avoiding apprehension, a mandated industry-owned cooperative to fight fires is highly warranted.
The three governments will need to join hands to ensure this outcome. Since the ASEAN Secretariat's stated mission is to 'initiate, facilitate and coordinate ASEAN stakeholder collaboration', it is the natural choice for commanding the regional joint fire brigade.
It is clear that to address the transboundary haze problem, we need to disabuse ourselves of the belief that garden hoses, cloud-seeding and a couple of light scooper helicopters with buckets can fight the fires of the magnitude we have seen.
The acquisition or leasing of firefighting air tankers, coupled with the efficient deployment of extensive material and human firefighting assets, comprehensive and enforceable legislation, close regional diplomatic cooperation, political will and finally, common sense, will help the region get through the present and future fires.
The outlook is not hazy. But if the most powerful three members of ASEAN are not able to address a recurring and predictable problem, what hope does the region have for economic integration with the ASEAN Economic Community that is going to be finalized end of this year?
Joseph Cherian is practice professor of finance and director of the Centre for Asset Management Research and Investments, Jack Loo is associate editor of Think Business (thinkbusiness.nus.edu), Ang Swee Hoon is associate professor of marketing at the National University of Singapore Business School, which is celebrating its 50th anniversary.
You might also like :
- Obama arrives in Bali
- Media mogul declared intimidation suspect
- Indonesia's Jangkrik field’s first LNG cargo delivered
- Australia sends spy planes to south Philippines
- Former US president Obama to arrive on Bali this afternoon
- Australian citizen denied entry to Bali due to criminal record
- Property developer sees potential to build office buildings for startups in Bali
- Indonesia's upstream projects proposed for strategic project list
- No extravagant ceremony to welcome Obama: Official
- Online drivers choose to stay in Jakarta to earn more cash