TheJakartaPost

Please Update your browser

Your browser is out of date, and may not be compatible with our website. A list of the most popular web browsers can be found below.
Just click on the icons to get to the download page.

Jakarta Post

Editorial: TNI and us

Today, the Indonesian Military (TNI) celebrates its 70th anniversary

The Jakarta Post
Mon, October 5, 2015

Share This Article

Change Size

Editorial: TNI and us

T

oday, the Indonesian Military (TNI) celebrates its 70th anniversary. Unintentionally established by a bunch of nationalistic militias in a collective fight for independence from colonization, the TNI has evolved into a structured, hierarchical organization that helped establish a sovereign Indonesian state and shaped it into what it is now.

Praised as a key unifying factor, along with other elements of the nation, during the struggle for independence and for being at the forefront in the fight against the return of colonialism and subsequent separatist movements and security threats in the country, the TNI was later blamed for abuse of dwifungsi (dual role) concept '€” with members actively involved in politics and businesses '€” and violations of human rights, particularly during the New Order era.

The commitment to reform in the aftermath of president Soeharto'€™s resignation in May 1998 has led the TNI to transform itself into a more democratic-minded organization, with a complete exit from politics and business being the organization'€™s most eminent achievement.

Reform, however, is apparently a never-ending process that organizations, including the TNI, have to continuously deal with. One major item of the unfinished reform agenda is the failure of both the government and the House of Representatives to revise the 1997 Law on Military Tribunals. Human rights activists have accused the TNI of using military tribunals to avoid the Human Rights Court and condemned the tribunals for their lack of independence, which they say prevents victims of human rights violations from obtaining justice.

A more comprehensive Military Tribunal Law would facilitate the establishment of a proper role for military tribunals, which are supposed to merely try violations of military discipline and not breaches of the law by members of the military, and allow the prosecution of soldiers who commit criminal offenses in regular civilian courts. Another issue still lacking in the TNI'€™s reform agenda is synchronicity between policy commitment from the TNI'€™s top brass and upper echelons and policy implementation on the ground.

While it has been institutionally decided that the TNI quit all its businesses, this policy commitment has oftentimes fallen on deaf ears once it has reached the lower and bottom ends of its organizational hierarchy. Media reports in the past 12 months have several times relayed stories of physical clashes between TNI soldiers and police officers at the grassroots level over disputed shares of extra income triggered by illegal security protection services the two forces have offered.

This specific problem has been identified as a result of insufficient salaries for soldiers and officers at the lower and bottom ends of the TNI'€™s and the police'€™s organizations, despite the annual wage rate increase.

The question is how insufficient is the salary of those low-ranked soldiers and officers when compared with their fellow Indonesians in the low-income bracket of society?

The problem surely needs a solution sooner rather than later. Yet, TNI soldiers are essentially no different from their fellow Indonesian citizens. It is only that they are civilians in uniform.

Happy 70th anniversary TNI.

Your Opinion Matters

Share your experiences, suggestions, and any issues you've encountered on The Jakarta Post. We're here to listen.

Enter at least 30 characters
0 / 30

Thank You

Thank you for sharing your thoughts. We appreciate your feedback.