Vaccinating teachers alone is not enough for school reopening, according to a teachers' association.
ith a mass vaccination drive for teachers underway and expected to be completed in the next three months, the government has decided to allow all schools to reopen for the new academic year in July.
However, parents have voiced their reluctance to send their children back into the classrooms as they are not part of the ongoing inoculation drive and over fears of a new, more contagious COVID-19 variant that was recently detected in the country.
Dintun, a mother of three in West Jakarta, said the government's plan was “too rushed” and reckless, and that inoculating teachers alone would not be sufficient to prevent virus transmission in schools.
“Children need protection, too, especially as they generally lack the discipline to follow health rules properly,” she told The Jakarta Post on Monday.
She would rather not risk the safety of her second, third and ninth graders by sending them to school in July, preferring that they continue online learning — as frustrating as the method can be sometimes, she added.
Read also: With no guidance, doubts loom over reopening of schools
Research suggests that children are just as likely as adults to catch COVID-19, but they are less likely to develop symptoms or suffer a severe case of the disease.
Around 168,500 people under the age of 18 have tested positive for COVID-19 since the start of the pandemic last year, or around 12.1 percent of total confirmed cases nationwide.
However, COVID-19 deaths in children account for the smallest fraction of all deaths among different age groups, with 0.8 percent for children under the age of 5 and 1.3 percent for those aged 6 to 18.
So far, there are no COVID-19 vaccines available for children. However, late last year, American firms Pfizer and Moderna enrolled adolescents aged 12 to 17 in clinical trials of their vaccines, expecting to have the results by June.
Arientha Primanita, a 37-year-old housewife from Ciledug, Tangerang, Banten, said she would wait until the health situation was completely safe before allowing her 7-year-old son to return to school.
“I feel bad for my son, who has been deprived of his right to learn and play at school during the pandemic,” she said. "But I’m worried that he might catch the virus at school and spread it to his 3-year-old brother and his 62-year-old grandmother, who lives with us.”
Arientha urged the government to be patient and wait until at least 70 percent of the population had been inoculated to reach herd immunity before resuming in-classroom education.
Read also: 'Long road' to herd immunity even with COVID-19 vaccination
In July last year, the Education and Culture Ministry allowed phased reopening of schools located in areas with low COVID-19 risk, or green zones, following complaints about poor internet connections and the absence of gadgets for online learning in remote areas.
The risk level of each region, sorted into four color-coded categories of green, yellow, orange and red, was determined and reviewed regularly by the national COVID-19 task force based on 15 indicators from the World Health Organization. By August 2020, at least 2,184 schools had resumed operation — 774 of which violated a regulation that banned those located in red and orange zones from resuming face-to-face learning.
Three months later, the government changed its policy by giving discretion to regional administrations to reopen schools — regardless of the area’s risk level — starting in January this year. The decision was made despite fact that the previous gradual reopening of schools had led to the emergence of at least nine new school virus clusters involving 54 teachers and 138 students.
Read also: Zoning not accurate enough, says expert, urging caution in school reopening
President Joko "Jokowi" Widodo said during the launch of the vaccination program for teachers late last month that he wanted all schools to resume classroom sessions by July after all the country's 5 million teachers were inoculated. Last week, Education and Culture Minister Nadiem Makarim instructed all state schools to use their operational aid (BOS) from the government to prepare for reopening.
But Satriawan Salim from the Association for Education and Teachers (P2G) said July was too early for the resumption of campus activities, especially considering the recent discovery of the British virus variant in Indonesia.
"Many parents told us that were are afraid of sending their children to school because they have not been vaccinated. The situation became more worrisome after the Health Ministry found a more contagious coronavirus variant in Indonesia," he said on Tuesday.
The association would rather have the government stick to its earlier plan of reopening schools only in regions with low COVID-19 risk levels while continuously evaluating their adherence to health protocols.
Read also: Remote learning takes mental health toll on children, parents
Epidemiologist Dicky Budiman said the government should not rely solely on teacher vaccinations to reopen schools.
“Authorities must ensure that the positivity rate has fallen to below 10 percent at the very least, the spread of the British strain is under control, and the death and hospitalization rates show a decreasing trend," he said.
“Vaccination is not a magical solution for the pandemic and should instead be part of a larger strategy, including aggressive testing, tracing and treatment.”
This month marks a full year since Indonesia detected its first COVID-19 cases, but the country has still not been able to reduce its positivity rate to under 10 percent. The seven-day rolling average positivity rate now stands at 17.7 percent.
On Wednesday, Indonesia recorded 5,633 new confirmed cases, bringing the total tally to 1.398 million cases, with 144,213 active cases and 37,757 fatalities.
Share your experiences, suggestions, and any issues you've encountered on The Jakarta Post. We're here to listen.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts. We appreciate your feedback.
Quickly share this news with your network—keep everyone informed with just a single click!
Share the best of The Jakarta Post with friends, family, or colleagues. As a subscriber, you can gift 3 to 5 articles each month that anyone can read—no subscription needed!
Get the best experience—faster access, exclusive features, and a seamless way to stay updated.