Prosecutors unsure about charges against Ahok : Expert
Callistasia Anggun Wijaya
The Jakarta Post
Criminal law expert from Gajah Mada University, Edward Omar Sharif Hiariej, testified on Tuesday that the prosecutors’ decision to indict Jakarta Governor Basuki “Ahok” Tjahaja Purnama under alternative charges showed their doubts about the validity of the blasphemy case.
According to the indictment, by commenting about Surah Al Maidah 51 during his visit to Thousand Islands on Sept. 27, Ahok violated either Article 156 or Article 156, section A, of the Criminal Code, which carry maximum sanctions of four years and five years in prison, respectively.
“The alternative indictments show the prosecutors’ doubts in determining the appropriate charge [against Ahok]. Therefore, they’ve handed it over it to the judges,” Edward said.
Edward, who during the investigation was a prosecution witness, said that he was unsure about the blasphemy element in this case.
Based on the law, someone who committed blasphemy should have the intention to do so, Edward said.
In this case, to prove the defendant’s intention, the court should not only consider Ahok’s speech but also his behavior in his daily life to see whether he had ever shown hostility toward Muslims, he said
“To prove hostility, [I] suggest the court listen to gestures experts to reveal the defendant’s expression [while he commented on the Quranic verse]. The hearing should be holistic and involve interdisciplinary approaches,” he said.
Edward said that if the judges doubted the blasphemy element, in this case, they should uphold the principle of in dubio pro reo, which meant they should rule in favor of the defendant. (dan)
You might also like :
- Indonesian firm to construct coal port in Vietnam
- No flight attendants in bikinis for Vietjet’s upcoming route
- Indonesia needs to realize its sharia economy potential
- Foo Fighters’ Taylor Hawkins: Computer-made pop music is depressing
- Trade Ministry, Eximbank to boost financing for exporters
- All Germany's gold returned from French vaults
- Headless torso found in Danish waters is missing journalist
- West Jakarta to collect tax arrears for hundreds of rental cars
- Russia offers nuke power to Indonesia
- South Africa's first online rhino horn auction set to open