TheJakartaPost

Please Update your browser

Your browser is out of date, and may not be compatible with our website. A list of the most popular web browsers can be found below.
Just click on the icons to get to the download page.

Jakarta Post

By the way...Keep on ‘trashing’, jobs depend on it

Leaders around the world regularly express outrage at the megatons of plastic clogging waterways, polluting beaches and despoiling the environment

Duncan Graham (The Jakarta Post)
Sat, September 22, 2018

Share This Article

Change Size

By the way...Keep on ‘trashing’, jobs depend on it

L

eaders around the world regularly express outrage at the megatons of plastic clogging waterways, polluting beaches and despoiling the environment.

No doubt reformers mean what they say, though one recent plea for firearm controls resonates.

When a deranged gunman shot staff at the Capital Gazette in Annapolis, Maryland, there was the standard gush of politicians’ sympathy — until an enraged journalist replied: “We don’t want your prayers and thoughts — we want your action!”

Even if all the official statements on fixing the plastic problem meant 10 fewer truckloads of trash had been reused or burned (in an emission-free power-station), we would still have a pile deeper than Merdeka Square and higher than the National Monument (Monas).

Wow! Let’s throw in the towel (for recycling); this is a mission beyond impossible, like getting kids to stop texting. The legend of King Canute offers a moving example of the stupidity of confronting forces bigger than ourselves.

The 11th century ruler of the North Sea Kingdoms, seemingly reincarnated in Washington, is said to have ordered the incoming tide to halt.

This is an early example of fake news, as academics say the tale is a load of old rubbish — but, like the White House press corps, historians aren’t to be trusted.

What we can report for certain is that the beach wasn’t piled with plastic. Had that been the case the tide might have responded to the regal edict.

My duty to personal health includes circumnavigating our suburb. Every dawn I encounter men in yellow uniforms with Petugas Kebersihan (PK) (sanitation officers) stenciled on their backs, one for every kilometer plodded.

This army of street sweepers soldiers on, seven days a week, and still loses the battle. Before they knock off, the sidewalks they cleaned are already splattered with garbage tossed by the uncaring.

The workers’ lives are like Sisyphus, eternally doomed to push a rock uphill which then rolls down — but at least it’s a job.

Now imagine if the polluters reformed and took their trash home. Then there would be no work for the PK crew and their low-tech gear.

They use long-handled brushwood brooms, the type common in Canute’s century and handy as pre-Airbus transport for witches. The best brooms come from kampung crafters; no doctorate is needed to deduce that when demand drops, jobs tumble.

Statistics Indonesia (BPS) reckons more than 7 million people are unemployed, and many more under-employed.

So it would be irresponsible to increase that number by chucking road gangs on the economy’s scrapheap — the logical outcome should we stop littering the highways and creeks.

The other victims would be pemulung, the men and women who rise earlier than the PK to scavenge anything sellable. If we reused rubbish ourselves they would also be elbowed aside by progress.

Let’s throw down the gauntlet (and pick it up again). Ignore the naysayers and run a national campaign to change behavior. There’s a line in the national anthem about “our beloved country”. Time to love, not just sing.

Mission impossible? Not so. Second president Soeharto’s prolonged and intensive Keluarga Berencana family planning program pulled the brakes on runaway population growth.

That was in an autocracy. With a democracy electors can chose to ignore urgings, unenforced by laws. Absent is the political will.

The default position is to do nothing. Eventually nature will adapt. A new organism will evolve, as we did, from the primeval slime, and devour the discards.

The process is already underway. It’s no longer possible to see plastic floating in Tondano, the largest lake in North Sulawesi.

That’s because it’s smothered by a green carpet of eceng gondok, the water hyacinth that spreads faster than rumors in an election year.

OK, it’s still pollution and killing fish; but at least it’s natural.


Your Opinion Matters

Share your experiences, suggestions, and any issues you've encountered on The Jakarta Post. We're here to listen.

Enter at least 30 characters
0 / 30

Thank You

Thank you for sharing your thoughts. We appreciate your feedback.