TheJakartaPost

Please Update your browser

Your browser is out of date, and may not be compatible with our website. A list of the most popular web browsers can be found below.
Just click on the icons to get to the download page.

Jakarta Post

Album Review: 'Affliction' by The Knife Club

Affliction is a propulsive album through and through. First, with “Cinema 1”, it starts off on an uncertain note: twinkling synths hint at nothing in particular.

Stanley Widianto (The Jakarta Post)
Jakarta
Fri, February 23, 2018

Share This Article

Change Size

Album Review: 'Affliction' by The Knife Club The cover art of Jakarta-based 'supergroup' The Knife Club's debut record 'Affliction', which came out in December, 2017. (The Jakarta Post/Elevation Records)

W

hat happens when a singer is tired of his own voice, even if for a while? The frontman of Jakarta’s indie rock band Sajama Cut, Marcel Thee, admitted such a transgression in a recent interview — where has his voice disappeared to? What’s with this timid escape?

So for his latest project, he invited a host of musicians (including Dylan Amirio’s project Logic Lost, Billy Saleh, Haikal Azizi, Jodi Setiawan and more), turned two of them — Baldi Calvianca (from the band Strange Fruit, among others) and Andi Hans Sabarudin (from the band Seaside or Pandai Besi, among others) — into equals, and made an album together.

That album is called Affliction, and the project is called The Knife Club. And this is where his voice disappears.

Though he sings in all of the songs on the nine-track Affliction, Marcel’s voice is caked with so many effects that it’s barely recognizable.

And all of these songs bear the same DNA that wouldn’t be unrecognizable on a Sajama Cut record or even Marcel’s body of work, which includes his ambient project Strange Mountain or his drone project Roman Catholic Skulls. On Affliction, this voice is his and so is this masquerade.

Affliction is a propulsive album through and through. First, with “Cinema 1”, it starts off on an uncertain note: twinkling synths hint at nothing in particular.

Business really takes off when “Downstairs in a Maze” lands like a thud — paying no mind to a smooth transition. Built around an energetic guitar motif and a cavernous percussion, the song hints at Affliction and its prickling sense of a singular sound.

“A singular sound” might scan as criticism, but with a resume as formidable as Marcel’s, you’d be hard-pressed to learn that these songs really do bend to one sturdy vision. But okay, they could sound alike.

What this album reminds me of most is, unsurprisingly, Sajama Cut’s recent LP Hobgoblin — a more varied collection of songs. Affliction, however, relies on more synths or synth-like guitars: take “Gracious Grounds” for instance, the best cut on this record, where the synths dance the way a guitar would (at times, it’s hard to tell the difference).

Affliction’s credits do attribute most of the instruments to Marcel (from a sitar to a Cathedral organ), but the small details steer the songs away from outright tedium — “Half Cities” begins with an effect-laden guitar by Jodi; Dylan’s buzzsaw animates “Stelarc”. While unconcerned with respites, Afflictionbenefits most from these tidbits.

“I Am the Red Circle” plays like a night ending with a quiet stupor — the math’s not quite right on the intrusive organ, on Marcel’s coked-up voice, and yet it works.

Lyrically, Affliction marches on with the weather-beaten temperament heard or read on Marcel’s previous songs. From dealing with “venomous liars” to “shallow humming villains”, the lyrics are indebted to horror or otherwise impenetrable tropes. “And I’m always drinking poison/and I’m always spitting lies,” Marcel sings on “There Were None Truths”. To scour for hidden meanings on any cherry-picked lines seems to be a fool’s errand.

Affliction’s strongest virtue, of course, is the musicians’ individual prowess — gamely anchored by the main musicians’ curation. At times, it may sound like it comes out from the same hive, but the songs linger afterwards. There’s something to admire from this collaborative bent alone and Affliction is one of its strong delegates.

Your Opinion Matters

Share your experiences, suggestions, and any issues you've encountered on The Jakarta Post. We're here to listen.

Enter at least 30 characters
0 / 30

Thank You

Thank you for sharing your thoughts. We appreciate your feedback.