TheJakartaPost
Please Update your browser
Your browser is out of date, and may not be compatible with our website. A list of the most popular web browsers can be found below.
Just click on the icons to get to the download page.
Calculating the cost of giving
New school transportation at St
Change Size
New school transportation at St. Yohanes with driver Yulius Katijan - JP/Duncan Graham
Orphanages, institutions for the disabled ' even some schools are run on charity, not government funds. There is concern that donations are shrinking as the government's tax take expands.
A hefty new motorbike van is just the transportation needed for the kids of Kalipare, a village between Malang and Java's south coast. It can climb hills and cope with the rugged roads even with a full load of giggling girls.
The St. Yohanes elementary school has 54 students, but almost a third live too far to walk. Few families can afford their own motorbike. Reality check: no free transportation, no education.
Fortunately, a generous person donated Rp 21 million [US$1,650] to buy the machine, which is pleasing news for the school. There are no company logos, so no commitments to commerce.
However, the gift didn't come with money for fuel, maintenance or salary for driver Yulius Katijan.
Consequently these expenses have been lifted from the general school budget. This means the 'library' will remain a junk room until another donor appears to pay for stock and refurbishing.
These are the sort of issues that poor schools in Indonesia have to juggle when government cash is not enough.
They are also encountered daily by Father Bonifasius Hudiono, 53, who heads the Karmel Foundation in East Java.
Karmel supports 7,000 students in 61 village schools and 60 kids in an orphanage. Some money comes from the Indonesian government, though Father Bonifasius alleged that local officials cut 20 percent off the grants.
He committed himself as a man of God after completing theological studies 25 years ago. Although he insists that thumbing a calculator hasn't replaced his commitment to the cross, his days are spent wondering when the next rupiah will arrive.
'Deus providebit [God will provide]', he said, and to test his faith checked Karmel's bank balance on his smart phone. Lo and behold, Rp 10 million [US$770] had just been deposited.
Didn't he want to know the source? He knows the person, but not how they got their cash. So if it was from trading stocks in companies that make cigarettes, alcohol or weapons would he accept?
'These are ethical questions that we haven't started to think about in Indonesia,' he said.
'I have taken money from a tobacco company's education foundation, but thought that to be ok because it wasn't directly associated with smoking. We won't promote the company's products.'
Taking a principled stand on moral issues is easier in countries where governments fund compulsory education and no one is denied schooling for want of money.
But in Indonesia there's little space to debate such niceties when the needs are raw and urgent.
Only three pupils at St. Yohanes are Muslims, according to principal Wuryanto. But down the road at St. Antonius junior high school the majority are Muslims.
'We are not seeking to Christianize students ' that's a lie,' said Father Bonifasius. 'We are trying to provide high-quality education and care so children in isolated areas get a chance to succeed. Parents who appreciate what we're doing will eventually make the schools self sufficient.'
He said that attracting business donations was becoming difficult as the government got more efficient in taxing companies, which are now less interested in corporate social responsibility (CSR).
'We've had money from Europe and Japan but these donations tend to be for one-off projects,' Father Bonifasius says.
People, he said, gave for a variety of reasons.
'Maybe a few think they are buying a ticket to heaven. But most are genuine, giving thanks for the church's help or because they'd like to share their blessings. We want people to give with a good heart,' he says.
'I don't sell poverty. When people ask what they can do to help the poor I just direct them to a specific need at a school.'
Endang Haryani doesn't get to follow her training as an engineer. Instead, like Father Bonifasius, she spends her time hunting rupiah for Malang's non-denominational Foundation for Educating the Handicapped (YPAC), supporting and training about 140 young people.
She's also had to look overseas. Recently she got a direct donation from the New Zealand Embassy and a rehabilitation charity in NZ to upgrade facilities at the school.
'We've been operating for 60 years and the government allows us use of the building,' she said. 'We need Rp 1.5 billion [US$ 115,000] a year for running costs ' we get Rp 45 million [US$3,500] from the government.
'The rest comes from donors. Although we've put up many proposals for CSR funding we've had only one response ' from a bank. Not all donors want to be involved with the handicapped. It's definitely getting harder to raise money.'
