House set to pass bill banning online porn

Lilian Budianto ,  The Jakarta Post ,  Jakarta   |  Tue, 03/25/2008 12:44 PM  |  Headlines

The House of Representatives is set to pass a bill today (Tuesday) that would jail users and providers of pornographic websites, despite fears the legislation could victimize receivers of unsolicited email containing adult content.

When the bill comes into effect, providers and users of pornographic sites will face a maximum of three years in prison or a fine of up to Rp 1 billion (around US$107 million).

"I agree if the bill is aimed at protecting children from accessing adult sites. But I am afraid the police will see it as a chance to extort money from people receiving spam porn emails," Zatni Arbi of the Indonesian Institute of Sciences said Monday.

He said the police could conduct raids before spam receivers had deleted the offending emails and accuse them of violating the law.

An information technology expert, Zatni feared the government's efforts to block obscene sites and emails would not work.

"The draft law may raise a good point but I am worried about the implementation. Censoring is not that easy, as violators can easily find tricks to access and provide porn sites," he said.

The Information and Communications Ministry has made available software to block websites with adult content. The software can be downloaded from the ministry's website.

It plans to begin blocking all adult sites starting April 1.

Some observers have warned the government may use its declared war on online pornography as an excuse to take action against other information deemed detrimental to the regime.

The number of Internet users in the country is expected to hit 35 million this year, a 40 percent increase from 2007.

Vice president of the Indonesia Telematics Software Association, Richard Kartawijaya, once said about a half of new Internet users in the country admitted to being tempted to access pornographic sites. Adult sites rank among the top 10 most visited websites on various search engines.

Information minister Muhammad Nuh said the government would call on individuals, corporate users and Internet service providers to help block adult sites.

"We expect to raise people's awareness of the need to minimize Internet abuse. We hope people use the software we have provided," he said.

He said the government had no intention to criminalize Internet users through the bill, but was seeking to educate people.

The draft law, which has been debated at the House since 2005, also spells out the standard legal grounds for all electronic transactions and stipulates overseas requirements the country's bank should meet for such transactions.

It also includes provisions criminalizing computer hackers and any activities that use others' Internet domains or change and delete information on certain sites.

Police are entitled to confiscate evidence from people suspected of violating the law, including their computers.

Those violating the provisions will face a maximum eight years in jail or a fine of up to Rp 2 billion.

Legislators said the bill was necessary to prevent Internet abuse and help meet the public demand for goods and services bought electronically. It will also help secure the trust of foreign investors and generate more inter-market transactions.

Comments (8)  |   Post comment
A  |   A  |   A  |   Mail to a friend  |  Printer Friendly Version |  Digg it!  |  Add to Del.icio.us!  |  Add to Reddit!  |  Stumble it!

This leads to the same contentious issue.. what is porn? Does it include for example nudity or online dating sites? Where will the line be drawn, and by whom?

ban porn....? thats because they want to open more strip clubs in kota. why get pictures when the real thing is cheaper..

Also an important note does anyone know that the internet would never exist unless there was porn! the only way internet exists is because of the contributions from porn otherwise no internet, Indonesia get real with Al Qaeda in a suit running this place!

only a matter of time before the same happens to you as saddam, dont think its a joke..wake up!

Its most funniest bill, how can they controll millions of people to stop browse the porn sites.

its police personnel chance to earn money in billions.

First avoid child prostitution in indonesian country.

Really its funniest decission

the host of representative just can making police but they can"t implementations for people of indonesia... i fear police department just want get money from people who do not know about these police

how about closing massage joints first!
Big Double Moral

It is amazing the country with one of the worst child prostitution / pedophile problems in the world considers online "porn" something to legislate against. "Those violating the provisions will face a maximum eight years in jail", so what about the man who sleeps with children?

I also love this;
"It also includes provisions criminalizing computer hackers and any activities that use others' Internet domains or change and delete information on certain sites."

Which, in the way badly worded laws in the RI are even more badly interpreted by the "police" and "criminal" prosecution "service" can mean people who post messages on forums and blogs. It seems Suharto's teachings of laws which enable corruption very much lives on to this day.

It's unbelievable that the government is going to waste so much time and money trying to enforce what is essentially an unenforceable law. They should take a lesson from every other democratic company that has tried this: without the kind of totalitarian and oppressive censorship they have in China, it's impossible to regulate the content of a transnational system like the internet. Instead of trying to pointlessly legislate morality (because if people want pornography, they will find a way to get it) why don't they spend the money on more pressing concerns like poverty and infrastructure?

I think this doesn't make sense, because the banning of porn will lead to prostitution, which will lead to diseases. Honestly, porn is the safest release of passion. And its good stress relief.

Today's Paper

  • Friday, May 16, 2008

Weekender

  • Education Interrupted