TheJakartaPost

Please Update your browser

Your browser is out of date, and may not be compatible with our website. A list of the most popular web browsers can be found below.
Just click on the icons to get to the download page.

Jakarta Post

What if Barack Obama was muslim?

A significant number of West Virginians (and some others in America) evidently take the view that Democratic Presidential candidate Barack Hussein Obama is a Muslim

The Jakarta Post
Los Angeles
Mon, May 19, 2008

Share This Article

Change Size

What if Barack Obama was muslim?

A significant number of West Virginians (and some others in America) evidently take the view that Democratic Presidential candidate Barack Hussein Obama is a Muslim.

In a surpassingly depressing report from the coal-miner state on the eve of the West Virginia primary, The Los Angeles Times notes voter views that go like this: "We do not need a Muslim to lead the good ole USA."

To more than a few Americans, it would seem, the very fact that "Hussein" is a Muslim should invalidate his candidacy, even though the U.S. Constitution establishes no official religion-and indeed guarantees freedom of religious choice for all.

Of this scenario, a quartet of things must be said:

First, it would not necessarily be so horrible if this well-spoken Senator from Illinois were in fact Muslim. It turns out that most Muslims, like those in the country with the world's most Muslims (Indonesia), are wonderful people who respect Allah, respect their countrymen, abhor violence and extremism, and generally would make excellent next-door neighbors.

In fact, very early in his life, Obama lived in Indonesia, before he returned to his native Hawaii, so he had met a lot of them. As a result, he doesn't think many Muslims are so terrible. That's because most Muslims, in fact, are not terrible-no more terrible than the rest of us, Christian or otherwise.

Second, if the American President were in fact a Muslim, you must understand that more than 1.2 billion of the world's Muslims would want to vote for him. Of course, they cannot-they don't pay American taxes, and not one of them ever voted for our current leader-George W. Bush, who is not a Muslim.

But if the American President were Muslim, Muslims would come to believe that America really is the land of opportunity for all-not just for white males who know how to fire people and then walk off with million-dollar bonuses because of how they kept costs down. Would the Muslim world's new faith in us and our political system be such a bad thing?

Third, most unfortunately (one might argue),is not a Muslim. So there we are. This politician is in fact a Christian.

Fourth, then there's the matter ofmiddle name. Doesn't that sort of automatically make him Muslim? Alas, no: The "Hussein" that landed between the Barack and the Obama was put there to honor his paternal grandfather. Turns out, Grand-pappy Hussein, of Nairobi, Kenya, was originally a Christian who converted to Islam.

That's sad. This fall's vote for the American presidency is not about whether some Muslims are extremist and violent-sure some of them are; but so are some of our Christian nut-cakes. The fall vote is about who should help lead America for the next four years. It makes no difference whether that individual is an Islamist, a Christian, a Jew or an atheist.

But, for the record, Barack Hussein Obama is a Christian, as are many West Virginians; as are many Americans ... like George W. Bush. Can't we all get along, and respect one another?

UCLA Prof. Tom Plate is a syndicated columnist and veteran journalist who teaches Asia media and politics at the University of California, Los Angeles.

Your Opinion Matters

Share your experiences, suggestions, and any issues you've encountered on The Jakarta Post. We're here to listen.

Enter at least 30 characters
0 / 30

Thank You

Thank you for sharing your thoughts. We appreciate your feedback.