A tale of Indonesian migrant workers

Indraswari ,  Kuala Lumpur   |  Sat, 11/28/2009 1:06 PM  |  Opinion

On Thursday, Nov. 5, 2009, The Jakarta Post published an article written by Silvester *Syl'Asa, titled "Migrant workers: Have we done our part?"

The article reminds me of the stories told by some migrant workers whom I encountered when I traveled back and forth between Malaysia and Indonesia, which I have done quite frequently in the last few months.

Their stories support Silvester's views on the importance of tackling our domestic problems such as poverty and unemployment with regard to the high flow of Indonesian workers going abroad - legally and illegally - in search of a better life.

At one time I chatted with a female migrant worker who was on leave to visit her family in West Java. We were about to board in the same plane from Malaysia to Indonesia. This woman was in her early thirties, married, and had two children aged 10 and five years old.

She had been working as a maid for some years in Malaysia. Prior to working in Malaysia she worked in Saudi Arabia, also as a maid. Her husband remains in Indonesia and works as a pedicab (becak) driver whose income is hardly enough to be relied on for living.

She left her two children when they were months old, leaving them under the care of their grandmother. Her prolonged absence leads to the children regard their grandmother as their mother and call their mother teteh, which means older sister in Sundanese.

She recalls economic reasons for working overseas and leaving her family behind. She wishes for her children to pursue proper education as she said "I wish my children would become clever persons *orang pandai* so they can have a better life *than their parents*".

On another occasion I met a woman in her mid-forties who happened to sit beside me on the plane on our way back to Malaysia.

She had just visited her family in Indonesia, the first time after working as a maid in Malaysia for three years.

She is a widower with five children. The eldest child is married while the other four children who are still studying range from primary to high school.

Her husband died one-and-half years ago and worked as a security guard (satpam) in West Java. Since then she has been the sole breadwinner of her family and leaves the care of her four children in the hands of the eldest married child.

She was thinking of shortening her appointment in Malaysia in order to be able to stay with her children but wondered, "How can I pay their school's fees if I stop working?"

There are other stories from other migrant workers I encountered at the airports and on the planes. Also in these places I often met those who needed help to deal with simple tasks such as how to fill in arrival/departure cards and customs declaration forms.

Others asked me to translate what was written on their boarding passes. In fact these matters may not be that simple for them, which is why they asked for help.

Traveling frequently between Malaysia and Indonesia gives me this unique experience, which is less likely happen when I travel to other places such as Europe.

There are millions of Indonesian migrant workers overseas and most of them are blue-collar. Many of them come from poor families, unskilled and with low education.

Nonetheless if we look at them through a different lens, despite their limitations, these workers are brave people who make a huge personal sacrifice and dare to take the risks to fight poverty.

Just like everyone else, they wish for a better life for themselves and their families.

I agree with Silvester who writes that many of migrant workers working overseas were lured by the dream of improving their lives and those of their loved ones.

Migrant workers that I encountered at the airports and in the planes are all legal workers with employers who treat them well. But there are workers who are unfortunate, being mistreated and even dead at the hands of abusive employers.

Yes, the protection of our migrant workers overseas needs to be improved. Nonetheless at home it is a high time for the government to tackle the roots of the problem, namely poverty and unemployment.

We can do our part too. If we are one of those employing maids at home, at the very least we must treat them fairly.

When possible we can do more such as helping them improving their skills, supporting their children's education or doing other things to help them fulfill their dreams of having a better life for themselves and their families.

The writer is an Indonesian visiting senior lecturer at the Gender Studies Program, School of Arts and Social Sciences, University of Malaya, Kuala Lumpur. The opinions expressed are her own.

Comments (2)  |   Post comment
A  |   A  |   A  |   Mail to a friend  |  Printer Friendly Version |  Digg it!  |  Add to Del.icio.us!  |  Add to Reddit!  |  Stumble it!   |  Share on facebook  
Ms Indraswari story is a familiar tale. I have spoken to many here in my apartment block. Some come from Medan, others from Surabaya, Malang and still others from Lombok. They all say they have to earn sufficient money for their families. Needless to say they won't have to be here in Malaysia if they could find work back home. They save every single ringgit they could to send home. I am glad to note that the ladies Ms Indraswari met have been well treated by their employers. But I have always worried about those who came here illegally. They are slways open to exploitation from both sides, the Indonesian fixers and Malaysian agents and employers. With the ban on further recruitment of maids from Indonesia I fear there will be a greater flow of illegal workers from Indonesia to Malaysia. To give your readers a greater perspective, Indonesian TKIs are not here only as construction workers or housemaids. They are on plantations, they are fish and vegetable vendors in the wet markets, workers on the supermarkets and stores, restaurants, taxi drivers, caddies and waitresses in golf clubs, owners and operators of small stores that open 24 hrs a day that sell anything from cigarets to cooking oil, sugar etc (mostly from Aceh), traditional medicine pedlars, owners of small construction companies, factory workers and of course students from well to do families. So we are quite interdependent. I hope Ms Indraswari can expand her research to cover areas beyond the housemaid business.
Mdm Indraswari story is all too familiar. These ladies she met have no other choice but to work as maids on Malaysisn homes. Most of my friends employ Indonesians who they find reliable and hardworking. A majority of these maids as treated as members of the family and entrusted with the well-being of the young children while their parents are at work. My own children had been cared for since very young by a series of Indonesian helpers and they are with a distinct Indonesian diction in their bahasa. Both children now in their thirties have been back to Bali , Jogjakarta and Jakarta and they speak of the glaring poverty they see there. I think every thing must be done to train the TKIs before the leave and the authorities should see to it that they are NOT exploited from the word go. The ban on Indonesian recruitment by Malaysians is a knee-jerk reaction and only deprives a number of Indonesians of work that their government cannot provide.

What's On