TheJakartaPost

Please Update your browser

Your browser is out of date, and may not be compatible with our website. A list of the most popular web browsers can be found below.
Just click on the icons to get to the download page.

Jakarta Post

ASEAN’s Summit and the morning after

The ASEAN Summit in Phnom Penh that just ended drew considerable international attention even amid missiles in the Gaza and another crisis in Europe

Simon Tay (The Jakarta Post)
Jakarta
Wed, November 28, 2012

Share This Article

Change Size

ASEAN’s Summit and the morning after

T

he ASEAN Summit in Phnom Penh that just ended drew considerable international attention even amid missiles in
the Gaza and another crisis in Europe. Much attention has little to do intrinsically with the group of 10 countries.

The summit’s significance is magnified through the lens of US-China competition.

US President Barack Obama took his first overseas trip since winning re-election. This was perhaps the last visit by the outgoing Chinese Premier Wen Jiao-Bao. Over the last two years, the Obama administration has made a concerted “pivot” to the region, whereas Beijing has seen alarm raised with neighbors over territorial disputes.

Obama did well. Recall his first visit in 2009, when he was assailed in the American press for being too soft. This time, he pushed and persuaded on both economics and politics.

In Bangkok, the US reminded Thais of their long-standing alliance and prodded them toward entering the US-led trans-pacific partnership (TPP) for closer economic links. In Yangon, Obama — the first American president to visit the country — met reformist President Thein Sein, and uttered the word, “Myanmar”.

He then embraced — quite literally and heartily — iconic opposition figure Aung San Suu Kyi and called the country “Burma”. The sensitive human rights question about problems in the Rakhine state was raised but had to be expected, given criticism that a presidential visit being premature.

Add this to strengthened ties with Indonesia, Singapore, Vietnam and the Philippines, and the Obama administration’s first term will be noted for re-engaging ASEAN. Credit goes to State Secretary Hillary Clinton, who has been especially proactive in paving the way for the president.

But another factor has been China. Concerns about Beijing’s ambitions have made other Asians much more receptive to American attention.

It doesn’t help that Beijing stands accused of influencing Cambodia as the ASEAN chair so the group’s July ministerial meeting floundered. This summit too showed signs of disunity when Cambodia’s draft statement led several leaders to reiterate their positions and insist on re-wording the text to salvage the situation.

Amid this, Obama did not need to stoke anxieties about China. He had instead the luxury of urging all sides to show restraint. When Asians can’t get along with each other, the position of the USA is reinforced.

Intra-Asian differences will continue after the summit. The Philippines — most vocal about Chinese maritime claims — has called for a meeting with other ASEAN claimants — Vietnam, Malaysia and Brunei. China is pointedly excluded.

How Chinese leaders now respond can potentially shape relations with the region as a whole.

So far China has punished the Philippines by cutting off tourist visits, bought over priced rice from Thailand’s Ying Luck government, asserted influence over Cambodia and provoked ASEAN schism. These cannot be Beijing’s mainstays.

China has always said it supports ASEAN centrality and its response needs instead to be broader and forward looking.

After all, China’s economy continues to grow while Washington DC stands at the edge of a financial cliff. So while Asians have welcomed Obama, questions linger over the American wherewithal to remain engaged and grow alongside Asians. China should put trade and investment at the front and center in its engagement with the rest of Asia — and not territorial disputes.

Accordingly, China would do well to give attention to something else that was launched at the Summit. This is the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP), to link Asia from China to India, with ASEAN as the hub, and others like Australia also in the frame. Despite all Obama’s charisma, the US is not within this economic group and
instead champions the TPP.

The RCEP sets the stage for a new stage in Asian regionalism, centered on economics. If it can make the agreed deadline of 2015, this wider effort would support ASEAN’s own target for community integration. The RCEP is still at a preliminary stage and there are many obstacles ahead.

But if it can progress, the RCEP can provide many avenues to broaden the agenda and create more positive perceptions about China’s role in Asia. Beijing should do all it can to help ASEAN move forward with this.

The writer is chairman of the Singapore Institute of International Affairs and teaches international law at the National University of Singapore Faculty of Law. He is the author of Asia Alone: The Dangerous Post Crisis Divide from America.

Your Opinion Matters

Share your experiences, suggestions, and any issues you've encountered on The Jakarta Post. We're here to listen.

Enter at least 30 characters
0 / 30

Thank You

Thank you for sharing your thoughts. We appreciate your feedback.