TheJakartaPost
Please Update your browser
Your browser is out of date, and may not be compatible with our website. A list of the most popular web browsers can be found below.
Just click on the icons to get to the download page.
The trouble with pedophiles in Indonesia
What does pedophilia actually mean? When it is applied to this case, where is the confusion? What is the impact of invoking this term if it is considered synonymous with child sexual abuse?
Change text size
Gift Premium Articles
to Anyone
Share the best of The Jakarta Post with friends, family, or colleagues. As a subscriber, you can gift 3 to 5 articles each month that anyone can read—no subscription needed!
Happy childhood: A silhouette of two children playing on a bridge at the Banjir Kanal Barat (West Flood Canal) in Jakarta on March 11. (Antara/M.Agung Rajasa)
T
he dismantlement of a closed Facebook group named Official Candy’s Club by the Jakarta Police unearthed the terrifying existence of an enormous network of child sexual abuse perpetrators. More than 7,000 members shared photos, videos, stories, and even tips on their sexual abuses.
Besides the obvious problem, what it is also troubling is the fact that media outlets refer to the perpetrators as “pedophiles”. Defying presumptions that “pedophiles” are “old men”, the arrested perpetrators are underage and in their 20s.
What does pedophilia actually mean? When it is applied to this case, where is the confusion? What is the impact of invoking this term if it is considered synonymous with child sexual abuse?
Let me be very clear on this point. There is no denying the serious harmful impacts of child sexual abuse. It is imperative to stop people using sex as a weapon to inflict pain and damage. But easily reducing, labeling and aligning individual sexual practice with sexual abuse prevents more constructive discussions that could enable a thorough understanding of the complexity of sexuality in our society.
When it comes to sexual offenses, to borrow from the scholar Roger N. Lancaster, Indonesia often acts as a “punitive” or carceral state” — overemphasizing punishment rather than addressing the norms and institutions that provide fertile ground for crimes to flourish. Last year Indonesia introduced chemical castration for rapists, dismissing the fact that sexual violence can happen without genital penetration.
The term pedophilia remains under-examined. Being children, victims are silenced, hampering critical examination of the term.
Sexual categories emerged in a particular period, and were constructed by authorities powerful enough to develop knowledge, like psychiatry and medicine. Therefore, it is worth examining how the birth and application of pedophilia does not always capture the complexity of sexuality.
