TheJakartaPost
Please Update your browser
Your browser is out of date, and may not be compatible with our website. A list of the most popular web browsers can be found below.
Just click on the icons to get to the download page.
Living with floods
There can be no denial that environmental destruction has played a part, if not the major role, in causing and exacerbating the problem.
Change Size
E
very governor of Jakarta has known very well that the city has to live with flooding as a result of its topography. Their success, therefore, should be measured simply by the severity of such flooding.
They may claim to have done a lot to mitigate the flooding, but the fact that Jakarta has become more vulnerable to severe floods shows the flood-prevention policies have not been enough or have been too slow to anticipate the speed of environmental degradation endured by the city.
There can be no denial that environmental destruction has played a part, if not the major role, in causing and exacerbating the problem. The loss of water-catchment areas, the disappearance of green spaces to pave the way for construction of buildings and roads, the exploitation of groundwater and human occupation of river banks for housing despite the law prohibiting any construction within 15 meters of a waterway are among the contributing factors to Jakarta’s flooding.
Heavy downpours are at the bottom of the list as we cannot do anything about them. Cloud seeding may work but it only shifts the clouds that cause rain.
Blaming nature, as Governor Anies Baswedan did when he attributed the recent inundation in Jakarta to the flow of water from upstream in Bogor and Depok in West Java, contributes nothing to the much-needed solution to the acute problem. The most recent flooding should instead inspire greater discussion among the leaders of Jakarta and its satellite cities about a comprehensive and concerted effort to prevent major floods from recurring.
The past governors of Jakarta left flood-prevention infrastructure as their legacy to spare today’s city residents from the worst.
Ali Sadikin, who led Jakarta from 1966 to 1977, built the Setiabudi, Pluit and Melati dams, as well as dredging a number of rivers to normalize the flow of water from upstream to the sea. He intended to restore the whole drainage system but gave up the plan because of the hefty budget required.
Wiyogo Atmodarminto, who governed in 1987-1992, initiated a clean river program that aimed to dredge the Ciliwung, Cipinang and Mookervart rivers. But the program failed to relocate squatters along the Ciliwung River, who he said were part of the problem.
Jakarta governor for 1997-2007 Sutiyoso prepared the giant sea wall to protect the city from flooding as a result of rising sea levels. The initiative was later translated into the National Capital Integrated Coastal Development, which later justified reclamation of Jakarta Bay for commercial purposes as sources of revenue to finance the giant sea wall.
Sutiyoso’s successor Fauzi Bowo launched the Jakarta Emergency Dredging Initiative, which aimed to normalize rivers, dams and major waterways. The World Bank extended loans to finance the project, which continued during the two-year term of Joko “Jokowi” Widodo.
Jokowi’s successor Basuki Tjahaja Purnama strictly implemented the normalization of rivers through relocating people who had settled on the river banks, which Anies promised to annul during his election campaign.
Indeed, each governor has had his own priorities in protecting the people, but for too long Jakarta has suffered from seasonal flooding. Perhaps a grand design of flood prevention that will bind whoever leads the city is what is needed.
